1.e4 b5!?

Sort:
Ben_Dubuque

I think theres an opening that needs expantion. 1.e4 b5.  it is a fun opening to play and is not completly useless as long as one knows how to play tacticaly

 

 

 

 

 

 

This is the position, you will notice that the b pawn for black is perfectly takeable and un defended. but is it a good idea to take it?  To tell the truth i have never played the white side but instead play the black side often as a "suprise opening".  Beneath is one of my successes with the "Polish Counter-gambit"

Though this opening is considered bad it is not worthless as shown in the above game.
Ben_Dubuque

The whole point of this topic is to explane and develop an opening that is little used

ill post the variations ive encountered and id like to see what a chess engine says about the opening from various lines

And to make this more interactive lets create an opening book for this with the main variations Pleas take one and name it
The opening book (P is for polish Counter-gambit)
P00:  1.e4 b5     Polish Counter-gambit
P01:   2.Bxb5     Gambit accepted
P02:   2...a6 Wing Defence
Ill add untill we reach P99
I'd like to thank the guy who made the bongcloud opening book for the idea
Ben_Dubuque

its not as bad as you would think, so far im undefeated in it and thats online as well as over the board

Ben_Dubuque

cause its fun just like the Bongcloud

oozecube2

If it brings you success, great. Enjoy it, have fun with the opening. Seems like if you run up against a strong player (>1800 or so) you'll just get squished. But hey, that could be arguably said for other gambits as well. I got told it a fair amount for playing the d4 Nf6 c4 e5!? gambit. 

chessdude46

I want to try and beat you, use that opening.

GMby2012

This could be very effective in bullet chess. Give it a go and see what happens. :)

GMby2012
GMby2012 wrote:

This could be very effective in bullet chess. Give it a go and see what happens. :)


My point exactly: http://www.chess.com/livechess/game.html?id=121565741

rooperi

I have posted about this before too, It's far superior to the Bongcloud :)

I've played 20 games online with this, 11 losses and 9 wins, which is about ballpark for a Black opening.

My approach is a little different from the OP though, my games go something like this:

Yigor

1...b5 and 1...f5 are the worst answers on 1.e4.

rooperi
Yigor wrote:

1...b5 and 1...f5 are the worst answers on 1.e4.


Just for fun, would you like to play a unrated engine game against me with this?

[edit]

Or anybody else?

Yigor
rooperi wrote:
Yigor wrote:

1...b5 and 1...f5 are the worst answers on 1.e4.


Just for fun, would you like to play a unrated engine game against me with this?

[edit]

Or anybody else?


Yeah, please launch it!Cool

rooperi

OK, coming up :)

[edit] I cant set up the position, please remember to play 1 e4

Yigor

doneCool

Deranged

It works okay against novices, but then again so does everything.

If you were playing someone 1500+ rating I'm not sure if that would work...

Chuckychess

After 1 e4 b5  2 Bb5, what compensation does Black have for the pawn?  Remember, unless you're completely indifferent to the outcome of the game, every move that you make should improve your position in some way.  In what way has Black's position improved?

Ben_Dubuque

The element of suprise my good sir                                                                                                                                                              Suprise

Lokaz
In my opinion, the surprise value is obsolete if white just develops logically.
Ben_Dubuque

but then black could take the center with the moves shown in the diagram

thus the position above is not hopeless

GMby2012
Lokaz wrote:
In my opinion, the surprise value is obsolete if white just develops logically.

5. a3!? followed by logical development is a valid option as well.

Surprise weapons have no value if the opponent expects it and is prepared for it. Hence, one needs a certain amount of luck for them to work. That is why most strong players use surprise weapons in a very small portion of their games.