best response to Sicilian?

Sort:
dripler05
When i'm playing as white, and my opponent opens with Sicilian, what is the best way to respond, sometimes i'll go E4 with knight F3.
Chuck639

Your going to get a mix bag of answers because there are so many anti-Sicilians, mainline/open game plans like opposite castling in the Yugoslav, Rozin and English Attacks, and lastly transpositions.

Generally at our level, an anti-Sicilian is best so may be check out the Closed Sicilian or Alapin, see which one you like better and stick with it.

Dzindo07

I don't understand the point of playing 1.e4 and avoiding the Open Sicilian.

najdorf96

indeed @ Dzindo07. I agree with you but not many players have the same resolve (as us) when playing the Sicilian. Many players play anti-Sicilians in the beginning to avoid Mainline theory until they have enough experience. As an analogy, I played the French Tarrasch for many years before switching to playing Mainline (Nc3) play against the French.

tygxc

@3

Theoreticians like GM Sveshnikov have argued that the open Sicilian trades a white central pawn d4 for a black wing pawn c5, which gives black a static endgame advantage.
GM Sveshnikov consequently played the Alapin 2 c3 which he thought more correct.
https://www.chessgames.com/perl/chessgame?gid=1140426

https://www.chessgames.com/perl/chessgame?gid=1070874 

From a practical point of view anti-Sicilians like 2 c3 or 2 Nc3 or 3 c3 or 3 Bb5 avoid the theoretical lines of sometimes 27+ moves deep of the Open Sicilian: Najdorf, Sveshnikov, Dragon... Smyslov and Spassky preferred 2 Nc3
https://www.chessgames.com/perl/chessgame?gid=1318001 
https://www.chessgames.com/perl/chessgame?gid=1049394 

If you really like an open Sicilian, then the classical lines with Be2, O-O, f4, Kh1 are least theoretical.

srishtygurjar

Khada khada fookda magazine si

SwimmerBill

At the beginning while learning, it makes a lot of sense to pick a response that narrows the opening tree so you accumulate experience in 1 structure faster and have more tome for endgame study. To me that means Alapin, Morra and closed are the big 3 possibilities.

ThrillerFan
Dzindo07 wrote:

I don't understand the point of playing 1.e4 and avoiding the Open Sicilian.

I don't understand the point of playing 1.e4 period!

 

1.b4, Best by Test!

Dzindo07
SwimmerBill wrote:

At the beginning while learning, it makes a lot of sense to pick a response that narrows the opening tree so you accumulate experience in 1 structure faster and have more tome for endgame study. To me that means Alapin, Morra and closed are the big 3 possibilities.

It makes more sense to widen the scope and get acquainted with more tactical patterns and structures.

SwimmerBill
Dzindo07 wrote:
SwimmerBill wrote:

At the beginning while learning, it makes a lot of sense to pick a response that narrows the opening tree so you accumulate experience in 1 structure faster and have more tome for endgame study. To me that means Alapin, Morra and closed are the big 3 possibilities.

It makes more sense to widen the scope and get acquainted with more tactical patterns and structures.

I agree .... but one at a time! (Someone once asked David Hilbert how he worked in so many different areas. His response was "One at a time''.)  - Bill

MaetsNori
Dzindo07 wrote:

I don't understand the point of playing 1.e4 and avoiding the Open Sicilian.

The Open Sicilian is arguably white's best try (and debatably the most fun!). Though it's also a huge amount of work, if you want to play it properly.

Some players would rather steer down a less theoretical sideline, just to limit the amount of studying required. There are only so many hours in a day ...

VulgarxGrotesq

2. c3) the Alapin variation https://www.chess.com/openings/Sicilian-Defense-Alapin-Variation

 

ItsTwoDuece

I believe it's best to go into the open sicilian, something like this (though there are quite a few other options for Black even at move 2):

From here, against most sicilians you can go for a setup similar to the yugoslav attack in the dragon:

The point of f3 is to prevent Ng4 trading the bishop, other than that the rest should make reasonable sense. While I don't expect you to see this exact line too often anyways, again this setup is pretty good, at least playable, against just about every sicilian. The idea is pretty simple- throw pawns at their king.