all 4.0-0 , d3 , Nc3 and c3 are playable.
though I think c3 is better than others.
it provides d4 : white`s got a good center and the black`s queen which white can gain tempo through.
Combatting 3. Qf6 in ruy lopez
Sort:
These are the sort of moves that are instructional to study. What are the pros and cons of the move? (I usually have my students make this list but here are a few highlights)
I am assuming that your move is Nc6 (not Nf6) since 2. Bb5 is a mistake
Pros - active square for the queen, defends the e5 pawn from attack, helps control d4. puts pressure on f2
cons: occupies the most active square for the g8 knight, which would help pressure the e4 pawn, and supports the natural counter central blow d5 , leaves c7 unprotected, queen is exposed to attack by Bg5 . Black also needs additional moves to complete kingside development and castle.
Based on this logic you can find some plans if you have a good knowledge of the various ideas in the classical systems of e4 e5 openings. the big question is does this move really stop the main plan of the ruy lopez of c3 and d4 in an effective manner?
I looked at few games by strong players and this is what black played. no clear win on comp but black is walking a tightrope to just avoid bring crushed.no fun to play otb with a clock ticking
To be honest I really dont need an IM or master to tell me that c3 is a strong idea and a very challenging one. I have looked at similar Qf6 ideas vs the italian game and the fail there too .
This was the line I used to play... without 3.Qf6, but later on.
Check this out, you need to. We made quite a big analysis (I think) about it...
http://www.chess.com/forum/view/chess-openings/ruy-lopez-smith-defence
Thanks for the help guys!
Sep 5, 2020
0
#9
Bogolyubov vs. Ed Lasker, New York, 1924 has Bogolyubov winning the game. There is an Alekhine suggestion of 5...h6 after 1. e4, e5 2. Nf3, Nc6 3. Bb5, Qf6 4. Nc3, Nge7 5. d3, h6 (Alekhine) instead of the poor move 5...Nd4; but I doubt it brings respectability to the idea.
Leonard Barden and C.H.O.D Alexander call it the "Frankfurt Defense" in their work, "The Ruy Lopez." I've also heard it called "Gunderam's Variation."
The Black Queen on "f6" is a bit of a mystery, one I don't like very much.
1. e4 e5 2. Nf3 Nf6 3. Bb5 Qf6
I despise this line, as I usually don't know how to proceed and eventually make mistakes. Black usually puts their bishop on c5, which creates problems on f2.
I figured it isn't mainline for a reason and wanted to know how good players smash this line.