Some lines in the Philidor Defense are critical. One has to know by heart what to do with the three best possible Bxf7+ sacrifices, or be so good and find out the precise moves to get away with these.
Then there is that one "bad" line: 1.e4-e5 2.Nf3-d6 3.d4-Nf6 (other moves being inferior if you want to keep it up with the Hanham set up d6/e5) 4.dxe5-Nxe4 5.Qd5! and black will struggle long before to draw, if they only can.
And this is the very line, that pushed Philidor Defense players, to seek for some improvement, and so was the Neo-Philidor invented: 1.e4-d6 (delaying e5). But then, one has to know what to do against various white set up, such as e4/d4/f4 and e4/d4/f3. Not a piece of cake
(sources: The Philidor files, by GM Christian Bauer)
Philidor played f5? I won't follow. I like post#28. And would study a dozen games before starting to play.