Does the Opening Explorer know what it's talking about?

Sort:
Avatar of PineappleBird

So I was trying to convince my friend that the Neumann Gambit is unplayable because Black has too many ways to refute it and White dosen't really get strong threats like in the normal Ponziani or real gambits like the Scotch etc...

Then I saw Chess.com claims some amazing players have played this gambit (Nepo, Grischuk, Ivanchuk)... However I can't actually see any of their games with this opening in any database... 

So is this just wrong or am I missing something?

Thanks

Avatar of TwoMove

It's most likely a mistake confusing position with similar one with Bc5 instead of Nf6, or something like this.

Avatar of PineappleBird

OK... hope they fix it... It would be nice to be able to actually see a list of master games by opening but it's annoying they just put random stuff lol 

 

and just to confirm.. this gambit is officialy trash, right? 

Avatar of TwoMove

I don't really know for sure, but would have thought so.

Avatar of newbie4711

You have to be careful with the opening explorer when it comes to transpositions. After ... Bc5 you are in a mainline.

Another example.

 

Avatar of Optimissed

It's just a bad move for white in the Two Knights Italian.

Avatar of Optimissed
TwoMove wrote:

It's most likely a mistake confusing position with similar one with Bc5 instead of Nf6, or something like this.

Yes, with Bc5 I think it would be the Moller Attack. You can't play the Moller against the Two Knights but you can play the Max Lange. So it's just a bad move and doesn't even deserve to be called a gambit.

The "amazing players" probably played it in bullet. It's rubbish.

Avatar of EKAFC

Just use Lichess opening explorer and search by master games. When I put in the explorer, I found this game between Radjabav and Anand which I will leave below

Also, you can use the Lichess database to look up what other players on the site have played and for whatever rating level they are, and with engine assistance to help guide you. 

Avatar of PineappleBird

lol Anand didn't take...

Still I'm confused as to why it says Nepo Grischuk and Ivanchuk played it dozens of times.. according to what exactly?

Like ok, bullet/blitz games you say - where are they? and why does chess.com mention them when in all the databases Anand Radja is pretty much the one and only master game in this stupid opening