Well, I really like the Scotch Game... (with 3.d4 instead of 3.Nc3)... but they are very similar...
It is perfectly logical... Developing pieces and attacking the center... It is true that it tends to lead to a drawish game, but I reckon that happens among masters, not club-level players... :)
Perhaps an even bolder approach would be 5.Nd5?!, the Belgrade Gamit :D Something surely worth giving a try in an unrated game :)
Have any of you heard of the four knights opening??? Along with the Scotch Variation, I think it is a very powerful and establishing sequence of moves. Many say it usually leads to a draw, but I beg to differ. Anyway, if you could post your opinions, it would be greatly appreciated.