I do not believe that the variant 1.e4 e6, 2.d4 d5, 3.e5 c5, 4.c3 Nc6, 5.Nf3 Qb6 gives White any theoretical advantage, in none of the pathes 6.Be2, 6.Bd3 and 6.a3.
French Defense Problem....
Sort:
Wolfgang Uhlmann has shown that the variant 6.a3 c4!, with the idea of a fast f7-f6 gives Black a good game.
schlechter55 wrote:
I do not believe that the variant 1.e4 e6, 2.d4 d5, 3.e5 c5, 4.c3 Nc6, 5.Nf3 Qb6 gives White any theoretical advantage, in none of the pathes 6.Be2, 6.Bd3 and 6.a3.
a3 is pretty annoying for Black after Qb6.But it isn't as effective against 6.Bd7.7.a3,f6 gives black an easy game.
Likhit, your thread makes no sense. Check the numbers of your moves, or give the whole variants.
schlechter55 wrote:
Likhit, your thread makes no sense. Check the numbers of your moves, or give the whole variants.
Sorry.
a3 is slightly annoying for Black in this position.Although i didn't know about uhlmann's Idea.
But a3 is not as effective in this position because of f6.In many lines the Queen can come to c7 to pressurise the e5 pawn.
Thnx for the info.I don't play the advance french as white.The reason i felt a3 was annoying because from the dvd through which i learnd the french,6.Bd7 was reccomended because the author considered a3 as annoying after Qb6.
Aug 9, 2013
0
#28
schlechter55 wrote:
pfren wrote:
The french LSB is bad only if you treat him badly.
I agree 100%.
Ruy Lopez: Black imprisons his Bishop on e7.
QG, Orthodox defense: Black imprisons his Bishop on c8.
Both defenses are alive, and played until now.
Many others lead to bad bishops, but nobody seems to notice because the Bishop has extra useless squares to go to, so it has slightly more room to manouver, but still is just flat out bad!
Case in point - Why doesn't anybody ever complain about Black's dark-squared bishop here? It's all about knowing how to handle bad bishops, not avoiding them!
and if black doesn't play the system with c4?
bluebird. You can say what you want. Uhlmann is better than you.
I am VERY confident about the quality of 6....c4.
Databases show NO advantage for white.
bluebird, I challenge you. I want to have black, and we play 1.e4 e6, 2.d4 d5, 3.e5 c5, 4.c3 Nc6, 5.Nf3 Qb6, 6.a3 c4.
bluebird, can you accept my challenge ?
schlechter55 wrote:bluebird. You can say what you want. Uhlmann is better than you.I am VERY confident about the quality of 6....c4.Databases show NO advantage for white.
The database can be used to make an argument but the remark about Uhlman cannot. The question is about the theoretical value of the move and not a player's ability to use it. A simple example:
A scientist says that 1+1=3. I say 1+1=2. Is he correct even if we assume that he is better at math than I am? When expanding on this example to less obvious situations we can clearly see how this type of thinking can be problematic.
With the same argument you just gave, I take the liberty to be sceptical: why is the opinion of a chess.com member more valid than the opinionS otherS ?
If the opinion is actually fact then it won't matter because there will be proof of a moves correctness.
bluebird gave only his opinion, I have read games and analysed them.
Likhit1 wrote:
Please don't take post #2 seriously.The bad light squared bishop is the major drawback of the french defense.But there are various lines in which this problem can be solved.For ex.
So after 42. Ke7?
Aug 9, 2013
0
#39
Bluebird1964 wrote:
Molokombo, quite right black can play 6...a5 or something else. But 6..c4 has been considered the most accurate move and the main line for years. I believe the system with 7.Nbd2.8g3 followed by 9.h4 to be white's strongest plan. This was my analysis from late 1980s early 90s. I believe black has serious problems.
you mean like this?(i might get the move order a little mixed up but it shouldn't really matter)
black looks comfortable to me because either white either capture en passent and black looks prepared to bust open the centre maybe after he castles if he wants or you leave the pawn and get mated on the kingside
I don't see how white can claim something resembling an advantage in that line.
Black has a few plans at his disposal, the most usual one being delaying long castling for a while and deploying the g8 knight to b6 (the queen drops back to c7). This is scoring well for black at all levels, and approved by Moskalenko, Vitiugov and a couple of other French authorities.
thanks for pointing this out. I was trusting my memory.