KID or Grünfeld defense?

Sort:
Avatar of VojtechTobiska
What do you prefer as Black against 1.d4? The King’s Indian Defense or the Grünfeld Defense, and why? Please share your opinions!
Avatar of blueemu

I prefer the King's Indian. The Panno variation, if I can get it.

Avatar of pfren

The Grunfeld was my first opening vs 1.d4 some 50 years ago. Eventually gave up on it rather soon because it had too much theory (now it is even more).

I have never played the KID as Black because it is strategically too complex, and it's also huge in theory (Kotronias in Quality Chess has managed to form a repertoire which limits the theory to be learnt down to just 2,344 pages).

And both of them are quite unforgiving- one opening mistake against a strong opponent, and you are toast.

Leaving aside the usual ultra-solid QGD and Nimzo/Bogo stuff, if you want to play actively and asymmetrically without needing to memorize a ton or taking big risks, the Benko (and its branches if white does not opt for 2.c4) is a fine opening.

But you can skip all that for later. At your current level, the opening is the least important part of the game, by far.

Avatar of Ineffaceable

I prefer to play the Grunfeld over the KID…… as white.

Avatar of Chesswhitebelt
Live spotting of Pfren…… what a rare moment
Avatar of blueemu
Tucker_CheckmatedYou wrote:
Live spotting of Pfren…… what a rare moment

It's part of our IM catch-and-release program.

Avatar of Shining_Star-01

 :messages