Forums

Nimzo indian

Sort:
John_Doe18

In this opening, after 1. d2-d4 Ng8-f6 2. c2-c4 e7-e6 3. Nb1-c3 Bf8-b4, Why doesn't white play 4.Bd2?



bresando

 It has been played, but has never been popular. Basically speaking, the bishop is very passive on d2, you will have to move it again soon or later. Also the move does nothing to pursue white's strategic goal of pushing the e pawn to e4. Among others, black might play 4...d5, with a sort of QGD where white has played a suboptimal bishop move (black is even threatening 5...dxc4/6...Qxd4 due to the bishop interfering with the queen; of course the threat can be stopped but this just shows how Bd2 is doing white more harm than good), or just wait with 4...0-0. Then if 5.a3 black can play either 5...Be7 (the "loss of time" Bf8-b4-e7 is totally compensated by the fact that white will also need to move the bishop again, and the extra move white has gained in the process is the hardly exciting a2-a3 push. So the tempo count is actually favourable to black) or 5...Bxc3. After 6.Bxc3 Ne4 7.Qc2 f5 black can regain the bishop pair at will and has reached his strategical goal of conquering e4. He is at least equal.

4.Bd2 is hardly bad or dubious, but still unchallenging and needlessly passive. That said, as an occasional surprise weapon it has been played by very strong players (I think even Petrosian gave it a go).

John_Doe18

Thanks guys

marlowe650

If you prefer to keep your pawn structure at the cost of tempo, I'd reccomend Qc2.  It's more active and strenghtens the e4 push.

John_Doe18

Well, I dont like to play aganist nimzo so I play 3. Nf3 instead.

JustinAkatsuki

 I heard alot of players try to avoid the nimzo indian as white..can anyone explain to me why alot of players tend to avoid it?

JustinAkatsuki

yeah but what are the challenges does white face when he has to go up against the nimzo indian? I understand alot of people don't like playing against it...but I want a lil bit more details

John_Doe18
JustinAkatsuki wrote:

 I heard alot of players try to avoid the nimzo indian as white..can anyone explain to me why alot of players tend to avoid it?

Nimzo is the second most succesful opening for black just after sicilian. So, it's the top choice for playing against d4

bresando
JustinAkatsuki wrote:

 I heard alot of players try to avoid the nimzo indian as white..can anyone explain to me why alot of players tend to avoid it?

It's a very strong and flexible defence; black has not committed his central pawns and so can play according to several different strategies. This means that it's a lot of work to prepare something against it, and white can't just apply a one-size-fits-all plan. He has to know how to play several different pawn structures.