Overrated Openings

Sort:
fischeryouth

I have posted a forum thread on what people thought the most underrated openings were but then i decided to make a new one asking for the most overrated opening. So plz post what you think is the most overrated opening system/move. My top picks for overrated opening moves are advancing either one of the center pawns. Not that these moves are bad but they are so wildly popular and praised beyond what they are really worth. Please dont flame this post with comments about my anti-centerpawnism.

fischeryouth

i hope you liked my new word 

Raibutai

Bumping is not appreciated.

fischeryouth

that was not a bump that was an add-on to the previous post sry for the confusion

Rhinotillexomaniac

He created the second post one minute after the first.  I wouldn't call that a bump.

fischeryouth

thankyou rhino now can we get back on subjecT?

fuze22

why can tpeople just edit their posts? i just dont understand that.

fischeryouth

i made a mistake ok lets plzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz get back on topic

Ep1c_pha1l

Uhh, the silcian, The most underrated is 4 knights spanish varation.

fischeryouth

hmm i find the sicilian quite good although i geuss u r right its like the center pawns 'good but overglorified' i think that the sicilian falls nicely into that category.

pvmike

the sicilian is definitely overrated, I've heard claims that it gives black an advantage.

RyanMK

I think Ruy Lopez. Again, not because it's bad, but it gets so much hype.

MapleDanish

The sicilian is definitely overrated. 

sableWhist

Queen's gambit

mowque
ih8sens wrote:

The sicilian is definitely overrated. 


i SWORE he was going to say Classical French

Jenkins12

The Sicilian works for Garry Kasparov, but a numpty like me pretending to exploit the nuances of the Najdorf is a joke. I don't doubt it gives Garry winning chances, but all it gives me is the chance to look silly for twelve moves before succumbing to the inevitable kingside attack.

Momadu

Although not too popular, Bird's is still overrated.

thegab03
Momadu wrote:

Although not too popular, Bird's is still overrated.


I diagree, the Bird's is well under rated & there for over looked & hence not common!

Ziryab
thegab03 wrote:
Momadu wrote:

Although not too popular, Bird's is still overrated.


I diagree, the Bird's is well under rated & there for over looked & hence not common!


I agree. The Bird is powerful and fun.

When I read the thread title, but before reading the initial post, I wanted to say that 1.e4 is overrated because so many play it exclusively. But, your anti-centerpawnism moves me towards defense of the classical style.

I think the KIA is overrated, and that offbeat lines--anti-Sicilians, anti-French, etc.--are generally overrated. Bizarre maneuvers to take an opponent out of book are overrated, except in the hands of Tony Miles.

ericmittens
mowque wrote:
ih8sens wrote:

The sicilian is definitely overrated. 


i SWORE he was going to say Classical French


The french is criminally underrated!!

And yes the sicilian is generally overrated, usually by people who don't play it.

Also, 1...e5 against e4 I find to be vastly underrated by most amateurs.