Sicilian Defense

Sort:
Avatar of TiagoDevesa

What do you think is the best reply by WHITE to the Sicilian Defense? (If you're going to insert long lines, please use diagrams)

thanks.


Avatar of Raito
Nf3
Avatar of KillaBeez
Open is the Best reply.  Anti Sicilians are the most practical.
Avatar of dalmatinac

3.d4

 


Avatar of CarlMI
FBI Organized Crime Task Force?
Avatar of BirdsDaWord
I have a question, seriously about the Sicilian.  Is there any variation where Black can provide ample counterattacking possibilities quickly?  I have been playing the French recently and doing well with quick counterattacks and not castling, but is this possible in the Sicilian as well?  Or should I just stick to the trusty 1...e6?
Avatar of TwoMove
I view the Taimanov variation 1.e4 c5 2.Nf3 e6 3.d4 pxp 4.Nxp Nc6 as a sort of improved French. Delchev wrote a nice book called "Safest Sicillian" about it. I used to play the French, so against "Anti" lines can use French lines, and gradually replace with more aggressive sicillian lines, i.e 3.c3 d5 then 4pxp pxp Tarrasch with extra option of Bb6 or 4e5 advance french with option d5-d4, replace eventually with 3...Nf6 lines.
Avatar of bastiaan
2.d4
Avatar of CarlMI

Seriously, if you want to avoid the Sicilian play 1.d4.  If you insist on 1. e4 the best weapon against the Sicilian in the ML Open variations, its also the most work.  How much time do you have to work on it?  Failing that try any of the following:

Feeling adventerous? like gambits?  Play the Morra 1. e4 c5 2. d4

Want to move away from standard lines quickly?  Alapin 1. e4 c5 2. c3

Other lines that work:  Closed 1. e4 c5 2. Nc3 and Moscow/Rosslisimo  1. e4 c5 2. Nf3 d6 3. Bb5+ or 2...Nc6 3. Bb5

I don't recommend the Grand Prix 1. e4 c5 2. f4  other there are others that do.

 

For Birdbrain:  The Sicilian is mainly about counter attacking, usually much quicker than the French.  In the Main lines look at Dragon, Acc Dragon, Najdorf and Sveshnikov.  Start another forum post for the question as Black.

 

To All:  An excellent overview book on the Sicilian is Starting out: the Sicilian by John Emms, published by Everyman Chess.  It doesn't to real deep but it will give you a handle on all the basic lines.


Avatar of michaelmcrobert
I like to play the Alapin.
Avatar of BirdsDaWord
I have a book on the Sveshnikov Sicilian, but the positions are absolutely mad. 
Avatar of northsea

You havnt seen Botvinnik variation of the Seni-Slav if you call Sveshnikov mad!


Avatar of BirdsDaWord
northsea wrote:

You havnt seen Botvinnik variation of the Seni-Slav if you call Sveshnikov mad!


I have seen the variation (don't know all the lines, but I think it is something like this)


Avatar of northsea
Best reply to 11.exf6 is 11....Bb7(!) which leaves  White with weak f6 pawn Wink
Avatar of ericmittens

The open sicilian is the most critical.

 

As far as anti-sicilians go, I think the moscow and rossolimo variations are the best of the bunch.


Avatar of michaelmcrobert
ericmittens wrote:

The open sicilian is the most critical.

 

As far as anti-sicilians go, I think the moscow and rossolimo variations are the best of the bunch.


How do they go?


Avatar of ericmittens

Moscow = 1.e4 c5 2. Nf3 d6 3. Bb5+

Rossolimo = 1.e4 c5 2.Nf3 Nc6 3.Bb5

 

edit: Here is a short clip from chessbase magazine 118 where Sergei Tiviakov goes over a bit of his game using the moscow variation.

http://www.chessbase.com/shop/images/cbm118/CBM118%20English.wmv
Avatar of pvmike
I play the morra-smith gambit, theoretically not the best, but it's sound. It gives white good winning chances.
Avatar of KillaBeez
Play something similar against all Sicilians such as the English Attack or a classical Be2.
Avatar of Fromper

As mentioned already, white's theoretical best against the Sicilian is the Open Sicilian (1. e4 c5 2. Nf3 d6 (or Nc6) 3. d4 cxd4 4. Nxd4). However, this has the drawback of allowing your opponent to play whatever variation they want, and you need to be prepared for all the major lines.

I play the Smith-Morra Gambit (1. e4 c5 2. d4 cxd4 3. c3). It's just as aggressive and attacking as the Open lines (even if declined!), and it avoids having to learn all the Open lines, but at the cost of a pawn. If you're aggressive enough, you shouldn't reach an endgame where that pawn would matter, anyway. 

If you want a safer, more positional anti-Sicilian line, I'd say go with the Alapin (2. c3). 

--Fromper