The Scotch game or Vienna game?

Which one do you preferer?

scotch

Neither!

Why?

Both are good.

Because with 1...e5 being IMHO the hardest response to beat, I consider myself fortunate enough to have decent results over the board with the Slow Italian - No reason to play the Scotch or Vienna:

1.e4 e5 2.Nf3 Nc6 3.Bc4 Bc5 (3...Nf6 4.d3) O-O Nf6 5.d3 and now:

A) 5...d6 6.c3

B) 5...O-O 6.Bg5

And as Black, when I used to occasionally play 1...e5, it was Petroff.  Now I play the French exclusively.  So I would see neither as Black either!

Italian until you reach 2000

Try Evans gambit

Oh okay intesting, thanks for sharing

Yeah I see what you mean but which one would you rather play?

Yeah it's on my list of opening's I wanna play

I answered that question in post 4,  and the answer remains the same - neither!  I would not play either one of them for any reason, White or Black.  I would rather play tic-tac-toe than either of those openings!

It's like asking a fan of Action Movies whether they'd rather watch Concussion (a documentary about retired football players) or You've Got Mail (a romantic comedy).  Response to both would be GAG and GAG!  I personally liked Concussion, but someone that only watches action movies would be bored to tears.  Well, not saying the Scotch or Vienna is unsound, and both have their fans, but to me, they are GAG and GAG (like Avatar and Titanic - two movies I really would GAG at having to watch).

Vienna for sure

if you remember that in the evans gambit white is not forced to take with the bishop he can also take with the knight so I play scotch game

the people who do not play veinna

or scotch

please don't post nonsense

please please

In response to spam posts 17-20:

What we have posted is not nonsense.  He asked a question.  Do we prefer the Vienna or Scotch.

"Neither" - my answer in post 4 - is a legitimate answer.

I am questioned why in post 5.  I answered with a legit answer in post 7.

Next, he says he gets it, but then is pushing in post 12 for an answer to his question, and in post 14, the answer is still neither, and will for ever remain neither.

Just because my answer is not what the OP wants to hear does not make it nonsense.  If I prefer chocolate, you cannot force me to eat the vanilla or strawberry.  I will simply pick, once again, NEITHER.  You cannot force me to eat the ice cream.  It is the same here.  You cannot force someone to change their tune and make them prefer the Scotch or Vienna if what they play is the Italian or even the Spanish.

An answer of Neither followed by legitimate explanations in response to a nagging OP poster is not nonsense!  Nagging and rewording is not going to get me to say what he wants to hear when what he wants to hear is not the truth!