Why would anyone play the French defense?

Sort:
lolurspammed

How is it not fun??

DrSpudnik

I've played both sides of the Winawer over the years and the term I'd use is "nerve wracking."

dpnorman

The French can be tons of fun, although it all depends on what you like in a chess game.

GrandmasterJalen

have you tried the kings indian defense? 

DrSpudnik

That's a 1.d4 defense.

That's a horse of a different color.

Robert09050

I would argue that fun is not the best adjective because alll of chess is fun.

J_adoubious

Maybe because if Fischer could have such difficulty with the white side until his match against Larsen in 1971 it might be worth playing?

DrSpudnik

Chess is not a fun game. You sit in a chair and torture yourself over the fate of some crappy pawn for hours. That's some pretty twised fun.

lolurspammed

...then why play??

DrSpudnik

A strange combination of masochism and boredom?

ParadoxOfNone
DrSpudnik wrote:

A strange combination of masochism and boredom?

You forgot the Sado...

I thought of a new slogan for chess.

Chess, the other Russian roulette...

Ziryab
Robert09050 wrote:

Many people seem convinced that the french is boring. For those of you who agree, please research the winawer poisoned pawn variation.

Some people think the Berlin Defense to the Spanish is boring, too.

Such people are worthy of being ignored. Little else.

kiwi-inactive

Isn't it just a matter of preference ?

ParadoxOfNone
Ziryab wrote:
Robert09050 wrote:

Many people seem convinced that the french is boring. For those of you who agree, please research the winawer poisoned pawn variation.

Some people think the Berlin Defense to the Spanish is boring, too.

Such people are worthy of being ignored. Little else.

I thought Magnus and Vishy made it interesting...

...I think boring players make chess lines boring, not the moves themselves Wink

Ziryab

I agree, ParadoxOfNone.

ParadoxOfNone
Ziryab wrote:

I agree, ParadoxOfNone.

Some people aren't able to appreciate what they don't understand....

TheOldReb

I have never in my life played the French Defense, which is the dullest of all openings.   - W  Steinitz     Wink

ParadoxOfNone
Reb wrote:

I have never in my life played the French Defense, which is the dullest of all openings.   - W  Steinitz     

That is a compelling quote....

TheOldReb

I like the quote but have been playing the french myself for decades .  Smile

Ziryab

After 16 moves in today's World Championship game--a Berlin--I tried to come up with something to say about the position for my blog (http://chessskill.blogspot.com/2014/11/carlsen-anand-game-11.html).

I failed to offer anything of substance.

I could resort to calling the Berlin boring because I do not comprehend what is going on. My approach to chess, however, takes another tack. The quest for understanding is life's excitement. This is as true in chess as in marriage and work.