euwe
Most Underrated Chess Player of All Time

Me when I was 1200 last year.
One year later = 1811 :) I have definitelty improved a ton since then, but I was also way better than 1200, too.

What about the Rev John Owen?
Maybe because Morphy killed him in a match at P&move?

Rob, people here tend not to follow links, but, anyway, here are some on various pages of mine concerning Prince Andrei Dadian of Mingrelia.
Lesser Known Games of Prince Dadian (in Seven Parts)
The Prince of Mingrelia, Part I
The Prince of Mingrelia, Part II
The Prince of Mingrelia, Part III
Dadiani
Dadiani II

David Janovsky, one of the best players of 1890s-1920s. He has a terrible statistics against Lasker and Marshall due to psychological reasons, but was played a hundreds of the brilliant games against all of the great masters of his epoch from Steinits, Blackburn and Chigorin to Alekhine.
I can't find his games in chess.com database and this means he's really underrated.
It must be me.