He is #4 in the world when much lower ranked players will be there. So of course there will be surprise. He also has a winning record against Kramnik and Anand. So his score against Gelfand isn't great, hardly the evidence of a bad player.
It's pretty obvious why Polgar gets so much attention. Aside from her attacking style and being top 10 in the past, she's the strongest female chess player of all time.
Since 75% or so of Americans are probably Nakamura fans i expect they will disagree with me, but why are they both the rage? i mean Judit has the highest rating for women, but why don't people pay for attention to players who are a lot better than she is? And as for nakamura everyone is just up at arms because he didn't get the wild card. i mean his score against Gelfand is horrible or Carlsen why are these two popular(not Gelfand or Carlsen) Tell me the last time Nakamura won a tournament and i will be satified,
CP