Banned accounts by accident

Sort:
eaguiraud

"Chess.com can't do anything with IP bans.They can block their IP bans and I guess they did so, the problem is that if their IP is dynamic (changes every time you restart the modem) they would need to block a whole range of IPs (the IPs are not random, they are taken from a certain range) the problem with this is that they could also ban innocent users." I saw this comment in another thread and it made me wonder, Can banned accounts be restored? I am talking specifically about this kind of cases.

Martin_Stahl

There is a difference, in most cases, between banning and blocking IPs. An account that gets banned, is banned for a reason but if there ever was a mistake, the account could be unbanned.

 

IP blocks could be removed if innocent users were impacted.

eaguiraud

Thanks for clarifying.

nimzomalaysian
Martin_Stahl wrote:

IP blocks could be removed if innocent users were impacted.

How do you conclude that the user is innocent?

macer75
nimzomalaysian wrote:
Martin_Stahl wrote:

IP blocks could be removed if innocent users were impacted.

How do you conclude that the user is innocent?

I think what he's saying is, if the IP block happens to affect, say, an entire cafe, or an entire university, then it will be removed.

nimzomalaysian
macer75 wrote:
nimzomalaysian wrote:
Martin_Stahl wrote:

IP blocks could be removed if innocent users were impacted.

How do you conclude that the user is innocent?

I think what he's saying is, if the IP block happens to affect, say, an entire cafe, or an entire university, then it will be removed.

So if an innocent soul gets his IP banned due to this, Chess.com can't do anything at all? That's sad.

nimzomalaysian

How about banning MAC addresses? I know its difficult and that no one's done it before but if you can do it, there will be no spam any more.

EscherehcsE
nimzomalaysian wrote:

How about banning MAC addresses? I know its difficult and that no one's done it before but if you can do it, there will be no spam any more.

MAC addresses can be spoofed, too.

macer75
EscherehcsE wrote:
nimzomalaysian wrote:

How about banning MAC addresses? I know its difficult and that no one's done it before but if you can do it, there will be no spam any more.

MAC addresses can be spoofed, too.

How about banning mail addresses?

Martin_Stahl

MAC adresses are changeable too.

 

That said, I'm pretty sure the MAC address of the client isn't preserved in the packets received by the site; the MAC of the last hop (router) is. The ISP of the client knows the client MAC but TCP/IP doesn't preserve it.

 

The client code could capture that, but again, it could be changed.

nimzomalaysian
macer75 wrote:
EscherehcsE wrote:
nimzomalaysian wrote:

How about banning MAC addresses? I know its difficult and that no one's done it before but if you can do it, there will be no spam any more.

MAC addresses can be spoofed, too.

How about banning mail addresses?

Nah, that wont work at all, 10minutemail.com and temp-mail.org/en/ will give you thousands of anonymous email addresses.

macer75
nimzomalaysian wrote:
macer75 wrote:
EscherehcsE wrote:
nimzomalaysian wrote:

How about banning MAC addresses? I know its difficult and that no one's done it before but if you can do it, there will be no spam any more.

MAC addresses can be spoofed, too.

How about banning mail addresses?

Nah, that wont work at all. 10minutemail.com and https://temp-mail.org/en/ will give you thousands of anonymous emails.

No, I meant like street addresses.

And if that doesn't work, what about banning State of the Union Addresses?

Martin_Stahl

Can we keep the State of Chess.com addresses? 

 

surprise.png

BronsteinPawn

Hey, I posted that lol.

Im not an expert on IT but I guess it works like that.

I dont think chess.com bans the whole spectrum of IPs (too big of a site to do that).

 

Regarding banninc MAC adresses that method is too invasive and you wouldnt be able to ban the MAC adress of any computer unless you make them download software (which I wouldnt, if they did that I would go back to chess24) as MAC adresses can only be viewed by others inside the network.

 

I dont know too much about getting a MAC adress but I guess they could get the MAC adress of your modem/router the problem is that most modems have a "clone mac" function and if they didnt have it you could simply connect your internet cable directly into your computer and look into the archives in your network.

 

There is no real way to ban a user from your site if they know what they are doing, but most of them have better things to do.

RonaldJosephCote

  "Can we keep the State of Chess.com addresses"?    Undecided51 States?Surprised   Ok,  we'll add a star to the flag.Smile

eaguiraud

Thanks @BronsteinPawn, I guess people sometimes do not have better things to do, lol

superchessmachine

now how exactly is this in the top 3?

skelos
nimzomalaysian wrote:

How about banning MAC addresses? I know its difficult and that no one's done it before but if you can do it, there will be no spam any more.

MAC addresses are not part of IPv4 addresses; chess.com do not see them.

(IPv6, different story, but IPv6 has been a "next big thing" for 20 years now.)

macer75
superchessmachine wrote:

now how exactly is this in the top 3?

Top 3?

superchessmachine
macer75 wrote:
superchessmachine wrote:

now how exactly is this in the top 3?

Top 3?

Latest posts