There's a new puzzle Difficulty setting available but it doesn't drastically change the level.
This is something I got from staff to share.
We are currently working on a significant overhaul of our puzzle difficulty system and puzzle ratings. Over time, the current puzzle rating algorithm created highly inflated puzzle ratings for our members — and consequent inaccurate estimates of a puzzle difficulty.
As we roll out our new system, you may see some inconsistencies in your puzzle stats, and rating changes from puzzles solved and missed may be greater than in the past.
We ask you to wait with us just a bit longer! Since in the coming weeks we will be publishing an entirely new rating system for puzzles for all members. We’re confident it will be a major steps towards our ultimate goals:
- Provide a more meaningful rating which correlates more closely to player’s Blitz and Rapid ratings.
- Serve puzzles better suited for each player’s level.
- Offer options to member who are looking for different puzzle-solving experiences.

I have a free account at Chess.com and am allowed 5 puzzles/day. My puzzle rating is ~2600 and until a week ago, was getting puzzles in the area of my rating. However, in the last week, the puzzles being offered are all around 1600. Does anyone know if this was a purposeful change by Chess.com or is there some way I can get back to challenging puzzles? Thank you.