1.h5 ....? not sure what black will do from here ?
I think 1.Nc4 is better ...Ng4
2.h5
I think first move should be Knight's, most likely Nc3 rather than Nb5 (Nc4 is out of question, since the black can have his draw just by exchanging the knights).
However I can't see a clear win.
That's the spirit of a study - the most impressive move occurs at second or third move. :)
Yes, Kauka, but you have to be able to reach the position with the spectacular moves! Try thinking your way through, also considering blacks best responses. In essence, what would YOU play in this position?
I see this possibly happening:
1. Kd2 Ng4
Moving the White King closer to the right of the board where it is needed (not Kd4 which would disallow the King protecting f2 later in another move), Black saving and repositioning the Black Knight to a place where it can have some effect in the hot area of the passed pawns.
2. Bc6+
If the f2 square is reached by the Black Knight, it would attack the Bishop and protect the Queening square. (Result being either the win of the Bishop for the Black Pawn or, worse, the promotion of the Black Pawn to a Black Queen after the exchange of Knight for Bishop.) This move retreats the White Bishop to safety from that threat and buys some time by forcing a King move.
2. ... Kf7
Gets the Black King closer to the passed White Pawn.
3. Ke2
Protects the f2 square from being used by the Black Knight to protect the Queening square for the passed Black Pawn.
3. ... Kg6
Again the Black King gets closer to the passed White Pawn.
4. Be8+
Black threatens Kh5 and capture of the White Pawn. This moves prevents that.
4. ... Kf5
Allows the Black King to cover the Black Knight and get closer to the action.
5. Bc6
Forced at this point, to prevent the Pawn from Queening (another check just gives the Black King another move).
5. ... Kf4
The Black King once again gets closer to the pawns.
... well, I have far (by a mile) outstripped by analytical skills ... and I seem to be playing Black better than White ... if there is a win for White, I have failed to achieve it clearly in 5 moves. This is no surprise because I am not a strong enough player to do that. If I were to revisit this position, I would use a computer for help.
Here's what it looks like after my tomfoolery.
I was surprised by the amount of resources potentially
available to Black.Matalino- There is a solution, the challenge is to find it. I have the solution along with the problem.
Peterkirby- The problem after 1. Kd2 is 1... Kf7 2. Ke3 Ng6 3. h5 Ne5 4. Kf4 Nd3+ 5. Kg3 Kg7 6. Kxh2 Nf4 7. Bf3 Kh6 with a draw:
Perhaps 1. Nb5 or 1. Nc2. I really don't know. I had focused, as my comments indicated, on preventing the Black Knight from playing ...Nf2 and supporting the promotion of his Pawn. I would be interested in the solution that you saw.
Matalino, would you please get off the thread? I'd say it was fairly clear that I was asking for people to attempt to find the solution, rather than me posting it myself. However, now that a few days have gone, I will post it tonight.
I didn't really see the point in just posting a study which people just look at and then leave, not learning anything.
Now I see the problem with what I was doing. A knight and rook pawn do count as a win for White, except in the case where the rook pawn has already advanced to the 7th rank. For some reason I assumed that applied to every rank.
Now I see the problem with what I was doing. A knight and rook pawn do count as a win for White, except in the case where the rook pawn has already advanced to the 7th rank. For some reason I assumed that applied to every rank.
Ah, one of the many annoying nuances of endgames! I've always loved that fact- never silly enough to advance it to the 7th myself until the time is right, my opponents so often fall into this pitfall in such situations!!
I have happened upon a kind of database full of endgame studies, and here I endeavour to share one with you. Feel free to post any comments and ideas below. It is intended to be a diagram, rather than a puzzle, to encourage active participation rather than people clicking 'hint' and then saying 'tricky puzzle' in a quick comment. Good luck!