Well there seems to be a LOT of questioning what checkmate is. I recall you going on and on about "entire position" which is not mentioned anywhere in the rules or the dictionary.
Untrue again. A discussion on causation and delivery can be about "entire positions" to show there is a better "delivery candidate" than a single piece in the checkmate state but it is not part of the definition of checkmate. As I said a million times "delivery" is about communication and not about checkmate/stalemate/... rules. And I clearly acknowledged that FIDE and USCF assigned delivery to the "checkmating move", not to the "entire position". Which is also simpler when describing delivery for all "states".
I agree 100% with what the rules say. I also agree with the dictionary. I agree with both the USCF and FIDE rules on checkmate. I agree even further with the dictionary definitions of both the words "deliver" and "checkmate".
That is untrue! You don't agree at all with what the rules say and seek refuge in a dictionary to find a definition that diverges from what the rules clearly want to relay. Natural language is never ever complete and never ever completely accurate in describing concepts and realities. Only formal mathematical languages are 99% successful in that task. For the remainder the job of the reader is always to read a text in the spirit, designs and contexts of its creators - such as by finding the applicable word definitions.
Uh, yes. I do seek refuge with the dictionary. As do most people. You can define words however you like, I will choose to seek refuge with the dictionary. That's where I get the definitions for pretty much all words.
And I agree with the rules because they are what govern this topic. The rules say both that a checkmate is an attack on an enemy kings square from which there is no escape and they also say that a move may produce a checkmate. I agree 100%. Just like the other examples we had. The entity that is in the way does not DELIVER the result. It move out of the way so something else can deliver the result. Deliver. Yes, I seek refuge with the dictionary about what deliver means. So would any judge, jury, or arbitrator deciding what words mean.