Is 4...Nd8 a known idea in the Italian? It seems extremely passive to me and gave you a big lead in development.
I'm not sure what the engine says but I would probably prefer white even after black takes your knight. Black's king just isn't safe especially if white gets the extra rook into play.
I would have attacked just like you did there. I don't think there is much that black can do to defend.
Well it wasn't exactly a good game, but an interesting one with a lot of interesting ideas and tactical opportunities. I know I missed a few of them. I miscalculated an idea completely forgetting his Queen could take my knight and went down a piece, but something in me wanted to keep fighting. I still had ideas and fortunately they played out in my favor. I hope those of you who see it find this game interesting and if any critiques or advice comes to mind, I am ALWAYS open to it.
Good vibes, my friends. 🙏🙏