Should white promote the pawn to a queen?

Sort:
laurengoodkindchess

Hi! My name is Lauren Goodkind and I'm a YouTuber for beginner chess players: https://www.youtube.com/user/chessdifference

Here's a puzzle for beginners: Should white promote the pawn to a queen?  Why or why not?  This position came up in one of the games that I recently played. 

CrusaderKing1

What do you consider beginners? I started in December but am also 1200+. But also not anywhere near your 2100.

Ilampozhil25

no

because stalemate

DerekDHarvey

Promote to Bishop or Knight and win slowly

DerekDHarvey

Crushing underpromotion in the Albin Counter Gambit

DerekDHarvey

Although the move 7 ... fxg1=N is check but does not say so in the list of moves on my laptop.

Is fxg1=N+ too many characters?

DerekDHarvey

If it wasn't check it would not work.

Ilampozhil25

it does for me

DerekDHarvey

Are you on a laptop? Do you mean it shows the +?

 

KeSetoKaiba

 

DerekDHarvey

I notice that c8=Q is not shown as a check. Is it too many characters. Other checks are shown.

DerekDHarvey

Promoting to a Bishop is much clearer and could be played at speed.

Ilampozhil25
DerekDHarvey wrote:

Are you on a laptop? Do you mean it shows the +?

 

both are true

Ilampozhil25
DerekDHarvey wrote:

I notice that c8=Q is not shown as a check. Is it too many characters. Other checks are shown.

what?

how is c8=Q+ not shown

while c8=R+ is?

or are you comparing it to something like Qa5+?

Ilampozhil25
DerekDHarvey wrote:

Promoting to a Bishop is much clearer and could be played at speed.

actually if say the pawn is promoting on e8, then the queen icon in the drop down menu is above e8, then knight is on e7, rook on e6, and bishop on e5.

so technically for that 1 move only, a knight is faster

Chiranjib20071

promote to bisop

 

DerekDHarvey

I am saying that a check is not always annotated with a + and that this occurs with longer moves such as promotion on my laptop.

DerekDHarvey

It worked this time for me. Are you on a laptop?

 

DerekDHarvey

No it didn't Blacks promotion is not shown as a check on my laptop

DerekDHarvey

It showed as a check until I posted it.