Illegal Position Contest!

Sort:
n9531l1

Here's #6430 with some pieces removed, still illegal.

 

EvinSung

 

eric0022
EvinSung wrote:

#6,437

 

 

I'm not going to be fooled. I always check my board orientation first!

EvinSung

 

eric0022

EvinSung's position (the post above mine)

 

 

I tried this far but realised that there might not be sufficient moves for legal retractions.

 

>> Black needs to move the a-pawn to the b-file and then to the a-file to get to a4.

>> The light-squared Black bishop must exit from b6, but getting to e8 after the b6 exit door is opened will take a lot of moves. By this time, the a7 pawn must have gone to b5 and the b7 pawn must have gone to b6 already.

>> One of the last few moves would have to be g3+ Kh5, but getting the light-squared White bishop out to d1 will equally take many moves. By this time, almost the entire of Black's army will be paralysed.

>> Now, Black only has one move left (bxa4), but White needs several moves to get the f1 bishop to d1.

 

With all of the above in mind, I conclude that EvinSung's position is illegal.

n9531l1
eric0022 wrote:

EvinSung's position (the post above mine)

I tried this far but realised that there might not be sufficient moves for legal retractions.

See #6387.

EvinSung

one move behind

Mikey383

 

n9531l1
Mikey383 wrote:

#6442

Here is a proof game for this supposedly illegal position.

 

SpeedySwindler

 

n9531l1
arjunjagan wrote:

#6445

A position with both sides in check is always illegal.

What piece(s) could be removed to make the position legal?

EvinSung

queen on a4

n9531l1
EvinSung wrote:

queen on a4

That's one of five piece removals that would make the position legal. What are the others?

n9531l1
Jai4chess wrote:

Knight on b4

If just the knight is removed, the position is still illegal.

The five removals that would make the position legal are:  Q, Q+B, Q+N, B+N, Q+B+N

 

EvinSung

knight is on b3

 

Nytemere

 

HandsomeDesert
Nytemere wrote:

 

How did the pawn on h2 get to g3?

Illegal

n9531l1
HandsomeDesert wrote:
Nytemere wrote:

#6452

How did the pawn on h2 get to g3?

Illegal

Can removing one black pawn from the board make the position legal?

Nytemere

Yes, on g6

n9531l1
Nytemere wrote:

Yes, on g6

Is that the only one?