Illegal Position Contest!

Sort:
daStrwbrry
n9531l1 wrote:

I need a hint. In your valid illegality proof, how many possibilities are there that have to be ruled out?

The target is the same in all tries: retract g7xf6. This frees up the kings and the other pieces stuck in the bottom right corner. To do this, bBd8 must retract to f8 (although there is a small try with having a promoted black DSB).

To do this, we need to retract bxc7, which first requires the black LSB and b-pawn to retract back home (this is what you have noted). The LSB can only get home by being un-pinned by a white knight/rook at e2; the b-pawn can get home once a black piece un-promotes on b1 and retracts all the way to b7. The various tries come from the many ways to try and obtain these "free" white and black pieces:

  • White pieces can be obtained by un-pinning wNg4, or by retracting black's axb capture. (There is also wRg6, although it cannot get out to e2.)
  • Black pieces can be obtained by un-capturing on g5 and f4 (with wPg5), or by un-pinning bNg2.
EndgameEnthusiast2357

How do you guys do this lol I can barely follow through the proofs with the explanations lol, let alone think up these positions!

n9531l1
EndgameEnthusiast2357 wrote:

How do you guys do this lol I can barely follow through the proofs with the explanations lol, let alone think up these positions!

I think being hard to explain is what makes an illegal position a good one. daStrwbrry has made some of the best.

EndgameEnthusiast2357

No I agree, but it's just so impressive. How do you guys make them so flawlessly despite needing 5 interacting aspects of the position that together make it impossible in the most subtle way..

BishopTakesH7
EndgameEnthusiast2357 wrote:

No I agree, but it's just so impressive. How do you guys make them so flawlessly despite needing 5 interacting aspects of the position that together make it impossible in the most subtle way..

Yeah, the composers on this thread are really really smart.

Megaminxcuber
TenGolf-Scientistical

really just a map of everywhere the knight can go in three moves

kon_fc

 :wp :wp :wp :wp :wp :wp :wp :wp :wp bc there cant be 9 pawns

Luna-I-V

*But nobody came

evdovkas

lol

Destructimetal
I call it: blocked. 
Destructimetal
Luna-I-V escribió:

*But nobody came

It's technically possible.

evdovkas
yerdeniz144
KieferSmith

not sure about this one

Ishaanharsha
n9531l1
KieferSmith wrote:

not sure about this one (#8955)

Easily legal.
 
ClipSpent

The most illegal position in the history of illegal positions

ClipSpent

Try beating that

ClipSpent

I just beat myself