Invalid Custom Positions?

Sort:
Avatar of LiquoriceKisses

I got the Chess.com app barely two days ago, so I apologize if there is a glaring solution to this... I’ve been tinkering with the app just trying to get a feel for how it works and I’d discovered the custom positioning option when playing with a computer which seems like it could be very fun, however almost any variation I lay out gives me the message “invalid position” and will not let me play! The only time this does not happen is if I make a very minute change like flip the king and queen, make a power piece a pawn and vice versa, etc... I’m certain this is simply me not understanding some rules, so I guess I’m just asking if somebody could explain some of it to me. Thanks!

Avatar of Martin_Stahl

All positions should have exactly one king for each side. No more than 8 pawns per side, no pawns on the first or eighth ranks, both kings can't be in check, and the player not on the move can't be in check. One side to move with no legal moves probably won't work, but not sure.

 

Pretty much anything else should probably work.

Avatar of LiquoriceKisses

@Martin_Stahl

Cool, thanks for the info!

Avatar of RVN32366

@Martin Stahl.

I experienced the same problem after I started using an iPad 7th Gen. I never experienced this problem when using my iPad Mini 2.

I like to use the custom setup to solve text book problems. If I inadvertently place an extra piece on the board (i.e. 4 pawns instead of three) and try to remove the piece by sliding it off the board, it seems to work, but I get   the “invalid position” error when I select Start. I am able to move pieces around on the board, but the app is very unforgiving if you try to remove a piece.

Does anyone know whom to contact at Chess.com?

 

 

 

Avatar of Kunigod

I just got the exact same problem, bur I can't find why it's not valid. None of the kings are in check, so it should be working.

Avatar of Finsharkotter
Martin_Stahl wrote:

All positions should have exactly one king for each side. No more than 8 pawns per side, no pawns on the first or eighth ranks, both kings can't be in check, and the player not on the move can't be in check. One side to move with no legal moves probably won't work, but not sure.

 

Pretty much anything else should probably work.

then how can i do this:

Avatar of Martin_Stahl
thecatlover2 wrote:
Martin_Stahl wrote:

All positions should have exactly one king for each side. No more than 8 pawns per side, no pawns on the first or eighth ranks, both kings can't be in check, and the player not on the move can't be in check. One side to move with no legal moves probably won't work, but not sure.

 

Pretty much anything else should probably work.

then how can i do this:

 

You posted on a 5 year old topic. Things have changed since then.

Avatar of Flx797

try changing the colors where you put the black piece instead put the white and vice versa. Worked for me 

Avatar of cl0msy

i try on browser and i still dont know how to do this, it says invalid and resets the board, not to mention i cant 3ven do it vs a bot. the only setup options are standard and chess960 or whatever it called

Avatar of Aris111182

I followed all the rules for custom, no more than 8 pawns, no kings in check, no pawns in 1st or 8th rank, one king for each wide, no player not on the move being in check. Wtf is happening?

Avatar of lambdascorpii104
Martin_Stahl wrote:

All positions should have exactly one king for each side. No more than 8 pawns per side, no pawns on the first or eighth ranks, both kings can't be in check, and the player not on the move can't be in check. One side to move with no legal moves probably won't work, but not sure.

Pretty much anything else should probably work.

I hate the no pawns on the 1st/8th ranks rule it should be fixed i have a crazy puzzle with that

Avatar of Martin_Stahl
BombCraft wrote:
Martin_Stahl wrote:

All positions should have exactly one king for each side. No more than 8 pawns per side, no pawns on the first or eighth ranks, both kings can't be in check, and the player not on the move can't be in check. One side to move with no legal moves probably won't work, but not sure.

Pretty much anything else should probably work.

I hate the no pawns on the 1st/8th ranks rule it should be fixed i have a crazy puzzle with that

The rules of chess don't allow that.

Avatar of lambdascorpii104

Okay how do i turn on invalid postions

Avatar of 123457nathanbian

How can I bypass invalid position

Avatar of haydenzalaker

why is nobody joining my custom game? It's valid. It looks super fun and It's better than the old salty normal games. So why is nobody joining it?

Avatar of lambdascorpii104
Martin_Stahl wrote:
BombCraft wrote:
Martin_Stahl wrote:

All positions should have exactly one king for each side. No more than 8 pawns per side, no pawns on the first or eighth ranks, both kings can't be in check, and the player not on the move can't be in check. One side to move with no legal moves probably won't work, but not sure.

Pretty much anything else should probably work.

I hate the no pawns on the 1st/8th ranks rule it should be fixed i have a crazy puzzle with that

The rules of chess don't allow that.

sad.png

Avatar of lambdascorpii104
haydenzalaker wrote:

why is nobody joining my custom game? It's valid. It looks super fun and It's better than the old salty normal games. So why is nobody joining it?

ask people in a club to join, might I recommend some good clubs for that?

Avatar of haydenzalaker

oh ok thanks and also yes i would the names of 3 clubs pls

Avatar of lambdascorpii104
haydenzalaker wrote:

oh ok thanks and also yes i would the names of 3 clubs pls

https://www.chess.com/club/the-great-and-extraordinary-chess-club (I invited you to that one)

https://www.chess.com/club/the-mark-mental-asylum

https://www.chess.com/club/royal-evil-cats-layottu (I also invited you to that one)

Avatar of VM_14

Guys, this error message just popped on one of my longest studies, on which I spent more than 6 hours analysing and saved for posteriority. Now I can't even open it. Any tips? Would be horrible having to do everything over again, cause there was even a lot of commentary and explanations...