french should be banned

Sort:
Avatar of ThrillerFan
EKAFC wrote:
yuann wrote:

There is nothing wrong here.

I prefer the ...Bb7 line because it is a waiting move and it can set up a trap

Works very well even at 1300 

 

Traps are useless!  The reasoning for moves should be on a more sound basis.

 

Yes, 5...Bd7 is sometimes played, but it does nothing to pressure d4, and gives White time to castle to safety with his king.  If Black goes for immediate pressure on d4, White has no time to castle!

Avatar of Chesshobbit69

I like the french opening a lot. First in my repertoire

Avatar of shadowarcher28

fremch is too op 

Avatar of EKAFC
ThrillerFan wrote:

Traps are useless!  The reasoning for moves should be on a more sound basis.

 

Yes, 5...Bd7 is sometimes played, but it does nothing to pressure d4, and gives White time to castle to safety with his king.  If Black goes for immediate pressure on d4, White has no time to castle!

It is sound. Just a lot of people play a certain move and lose a pawn in the center. Also, it allows you to castle queenside if needed in case you want to open up the kingside.

Avatar of yuann
shadowarcher28 wrote:

fremch is too op 

I feel like those who say that don't really understand the opening... You should look at some of the old lessons on the French defense.

Avatar of yuann
yuann wrote:
shadowarcher28 wrote:

fremch is too op 

I feel like those who say that don't really understand the opening... You should look at some of the old lessons on the French defense.

Additionally try it our urself, it's a lot harder than you think

Avatar of shadowarcher28
yuann wrote:
shadowarcher28 wrote:

fremch is too op 

I feel like those who say that don't really understand the opening... You should look at some of the old lessons on the French defense.

bruh im kidding i play french all the time 

Avatar of yuann
shadowarcher28 wrote:
yuann wrote:
shadowarcher28 wrote:

fremch is too op 

I feel like those who say that don't really understand the opening... You should look at some of the old lessons on the French defense.

bruh im kidding i play french all the time 

oh tongue.png

Avatar of mpaetz

     We're getting a lot of discussion here about a couple of moves in just one variation of the French--not the main lines and not the most common variation. This seems to indicate that there are a lot of interesting ideas  in this defense.

Avatar of 10_Dice

No it shouldn't be banned. What are you going to argue next stalemate should be banned too ? 

Avatar of ThrillerFan
10_Dice wrote:

No it shouldn't be banned. What are you going to argue next stalemate should be banned too ? 

No!  Defeating me is banned!  You play me, you must lose or draw!