Chess : science or art?

Sort:
d4e4
[COMMENT DELETED]
1pawndown

I vote for "Art."

d4e4
[COMMENT DELETED]
Annabelle

'Chess is the art which expresses the science of logic'. Mikhail Botvinnik

ruthus
ChessStrategist wrote:

Ah...chess...let me see...it is like the wafting fragrance of daffidils blossoming in the springtime. It is a chimera...a flute in the wind...a vicarious embattlement...a Machiavellian sonnet of wits...

See, I can wax eloquently about chess, too. Ugh! Now I feel abdominal cramps coming...bucket!!!


 Mmmm not bad you started off like William Wordsworth but ended up more like Eddie Murphy!!

d4e4
[COMMENT DELETED]
Phantomgreenqbs

There is an inherent connection between art and science, and chess illustrates that relationship quite beautifully...

d4e4

Wow! How utterly profound!

americanfighter

i say it is a science and an art. think about it we set value on the differint peaces we evaluate risks vs rewards and probablity of a move. The we go back and evaluate games and addapt and we studdy openings. we use creativity to form stratagy 

d4e4
[COMMENT DELETED]
person-142343534

Since when was there an art that wasn't a science?

batgirl
lefecious wrote:
Cicero:  Philosopher or Orator?

Quousque tandem abutere, Catalina, patientia nostra?

d4e4

Quid rides? Mutato nomine de te fabula narratur.

fyy0r

Chess is science.  Mastering this science is where the beauty of art can come in.

ekorbdal

Ruthus' reply is both eloquent, succinct and so - in my view - just about sais it all.

ruthus
americanfighter wrote:

i say it is a science and an art. think about it we set value on the differint peaces we evaluate risks vs rewards and probablity of a move. The we go back and evaluate games and addapt and we studdy openings. we use creativity to form stratagy 


 Sounds suspiciously like life...who said life wasn't a science? In fact, the words conscience and science are etymologically linked; to partly quote Sir Michael Caine : ' And not many people know that'!

d4e4
[COMMENT DELETED]
madhacker

The "black box" is of course just a machine with zero intelligence, but the ability to process huge numbers very quickly. Sadly, this rather moronic trait more than compensates for its inability to think.

Especially when you give it one of your positions to look at, it pauses for a few seconds, then plays a move that you considered and rejected, and announces mate in 25 (Yes, this has happened to me).

Mwhahaha. Pathetic, feeble human.

d4e4
[COMMENT DELETED]
madhacker

But how long before computers can do that as well? Laughing