Chess will never be solved, here's why

Sort:
MARattigan

Agreed. But what we are discussing is forging metal. The Wikipaedia definitions bear little relation to the discussion.

DiogenesDue
MARattigan wrote:

Agreed. But what we are discussing is forging metal. The Wikipaedia definitions bear little relation to the discussion.

True enough, but for munchkins that come along and don't read anything, then declare chess to be solved because engines beat GMs, they are effectively back on page 1 on the thread.

MARattigan

No doubt, but not a lot to be done about that.

It's not just this discussion though. There are occasional headlines such as "connect 4 is solved" or "checkers is solved", when according to the Wikipaedia definition they've been solved since they were first invented.

Elroch

There is an objective criterion that excludes your thinking - the solution has to include the determination of the value of the game.

Dtorralba

This is one hell of a rabbit hole

MARattigan

@Elroch

Only for the ultra weak solution if I read Wikipaedia right.

In any case it does. You just use the strategy/strategies on the starting position and your ghost finds out what the value is.

DiogenesDue
Dtorralba wrote:

This is one hell of a rabbit hole

Ultimately, there's no reason to exist that is more important than any other beyond your relationships with others.  So if you are doing those justice, then exploring the most stuff that interests you would seem to be the best way to go.  Who wants to end their life with a bunch of questions unanswered?

MARattigan
Dtorralba wrote:

This is one hell of a rabbit hole

If you want to talk to the Mad Hatter, his id is @tygxc.

MEGACHE3SE
btickler wrote:
Dtorralba wrote:

This is one hell of a rabbit hole

Ultimately, there's no reason to exist that is more important than any other beyond your relationships with others.  So if you are doing those justice, then exploring the most stuff that interests you would seem to be the best way to go.  Who wants to end their life with a bunch of questions unanswered?

what does the b in btickler stand for.

MARattigan

Whatever he says, you'ld probably get a different answer from @Optimissed.

DiogenesDue
MEGACHE3SE wrote:

what does the b in btickler stand for.

Nothing you would understand.

What is the existential meaning of the username Megacheese?

tygxc

@7543

"ICCF players do nothing more then use the chess engines for their moves."
++ They do much more. They analyse played games in data bases.
They anticipate opponent's engine moves.

"And as the chess engines increase in playing strength. So do the ICCF players."
++ Yes, over the years they err less and draw more.

"But the ICCF players do not play better then the imperfect chess engines."
++ They do. If you doubt that, then enter an ICCF tournament and play the moves by your engine and see how much you lose. ICCF players exploit the imperfections of engines.

MEGACHE3SE
btickler wrote:
MEGACHE3SE wrote:

what does the b in btickler stand for.

Nothing you would understand.

What is the existential meaning of the username Megacheese?

My cheese is mega, what about u?

tygxc

@7544

"If ICCF players have already solved chess then there's no need to wait 5 years with a supercomputer and Sveshnikov's ghost."
++ ICCF players have not solved chess, but they often play perfect chess with optimal play from both sides to draws, but not always: there are still a few decisive games, i.e. with errors.
Over the years they make fewer and fewer errors and draw more.
They still take 2 years with engines to play such a perfect game with optimal play by both sides.

MEGACHE3SE
Squid wrote:

to all the stupid people who think that chess will never be solved 🙄 here is a perfect 50 move game played by me

htttps://chess.com/game/live/7012649216

dam

MEGACHE3SE
btickler wrote:
MEGACHE3SE wrote:

what does the b in btickler stand for.

Nothing you would understand.

What is the existential meaning of the username Megacheese?

I swear to god if its "butt tickler" I will cancel you on twitter

MEGACHE3SE

wait i think theres just some absolute dingus downvoting EVERYONE'S posts rn.  i propose that we just upvote indiscriminately as a frick u to that guy

MEGACHE3SE
shangtsung111 wrote:
MEGACHE3SE wrote:

wait i think theres just some absolute dingus downvoting EVERYONE'S posts rn.  i propose that we just upvote indiscriminately as a frick u to that guy

even my positive emoji with no words was downvoted. has to be a hater.

aight im upvoting everything, u down?

monkey

Chess can be solved, so it will be solved unless we all die. Eventually we can have a computer powerful enough to solve chess. And eventually those computers will become everyday items like laptops

tygxc

@7607

"how many trillions of times faster does a computer need to be to solve chess"
++ Existing computers of 10^9 nodes/s can weakly solve Chess in 5 years exhausting all 10^17 relevant positions.