Choosing an Indian

Sort:
marknatm
Why when discussing the Indian Openings nearly everyone recommends the Nimzo or Bogo, stays kinda silent about the Queen's Indian, and thinks the King's Indian is a bad opening. Heaven forbid you mention the Old Indian -"What? Are you crazy?"
marknatm

So, I understand that Serawan's book on openings suggests the King's Indian. Why is that everyone else prefers the Nimzo or Bogo? I'm still puzzled as to why the Old Indian is considered bad.

MickinMD

Because it sounds cool to say "Nimzo."

gingerninja2003

i used to play the KID but i didn't like it. i now play the nimzo Indian or the QID with Ba6.

thatwhichpasses

I wish there was a line called the Nimzobogo. 

marknatm

I think there are plenty of transposition opportunities from Nimzo to Bogo, so Nimzobogo might be appropriate. I'm just wondering what would be the best choice if you have limited study time. Seirawan says King's Indian, Tamburro says Nimzo, I think that the Old might be more offbeat, but I don't know any of them.

Nimzowitsch2017

the nimzo indian creates the least weaknesses and allows black to castle early

Derekjj

In choosing an Indian, you would need a nose plug because they smell bad. . Might be a good idea to get vaccinated. You must also know that the indian is a possible scammer.

mkkuhner

I recommend playing over half a dozen games in each and seeing which one produces positions you like and feel you can understand.  That's a lot more relevant than strangers' opinions.  I picked my Black openings this way when I was in my teens and they have served me pretty well.

marknatm

Thank you Mary Kuhner.

The_Ghostess_Lola

Does Bogo mean....Buy one get one ?

FaceCrusher

Whoever said the King's Indian is bad needs their heads examined. Or maybe better yet, try and explain why Bobby Fischer and Garry Kasparov, who made careers out of playing the King's Indian, were wrong. 

 

You can't do better than mkkuhner's advice. In the end, we are all blowing hot air until you just sit down with someone or even a computer, and try the openings out for yourself for about a month. Just try 3 or 4, a week at a time and see which one you like. You'll know based on how it feels better than someone telling you what to play. 

FaceCrusher
[COMMENT DELETED]
camter
FaceCrusher wrote:

Whoever said the King's Indian is bad needs their heads examined. Or maybe better yet, try and explain why Bobby Fischer and Garry Kasparov, who made careers out of playing the King's Indian, were wrong. 

 

You can't do better than mkkuhner's advice. In the end, we are all blowing hot air until you just sit down with someone or even a computer, and try the openings out for yourself for about a month. Just try 3 or 4, a week at a time and see which one you like. You'll know based on how it feels better than someone telling you what to play. 

I have a feeling that Fischer and Kasparov would only play the KID today against someone they were sure did not know its inherent weaknesses.

snakey77

don't play queen's indian, it's too op, have you ever met a player who would rather play against the queen's indian than those other options? a lot of people avoid nf3 and go for ne2 plans instead just because of the queen's indian. I recommend the king's indian, but only this variation, I don't really like the mainline

old indian is fine, Bronstein sometimes played it so you can look at some of his games.

but yeah, please look into that variation of the king's indian, hardly anybody plays it and it deserves more recognition imo

camter

I may be wrong, but i think the Nimzo is not used by top players who are desperate for a Win. Meaning they will not want a draw, and will accept a loss if the opponent is good enough as a risk they are willing to take.  

gingerninja2003

the chicken korma is the Indian i pick.

The_Ghostess_Lola

Have u considered Tecumseh ?