Did I win this chess game dishonestly?

Sort:
Eo____
heinzie wrote:

No sorry I'm the non-playing type of troll


then join anyway. you don't have to play...

ivandh
Eo____ wrote:
heinzie wrote:

No sorry I'm the non-playing type of troll


then join and withdraw after the tournament starts :)


Or make each move in the last 30 seconds

Eo____
heinzie wrote:

You won the game, but you lost your dignity... and a friend


True. He sent me an unfriendly message aftewards :(

SchofieldKid

Nice but in Real life tourney chess that is enough checks for a draw anyways +)

SavageLotus

You got lucky. Its all fair.

orangehonda
Eo____ wrote:
orangehonda wrote:

I like how you immediately follow up the sacrifice with 1) getting rid of your most active piece 2) forcing white to centralize his knight and 3) the move that brings it all together Rab1

It wasn't a dishonest win, you both played by the rules.


I played as Black.

 

"Did you consider 34. ...RxR  ?"

 

Yes.


Heh, I got confused.  Was only going to give you a hard time because I knew you could play better than that... turns out it wasn't you in the first place.

orangehonda
Estragon wrote:

Perennial US Champion from the early 20th Century Frank Marshall called such wins "swindles."  A win is a win, though.

Who resigns once their opponent has achieved a "theoretically won position" in chess?  No one - we make the opponent show he knows how to win it.  Most often he will, but sometimes he slips and allows a draw or even loses.  There is no shame in a successful defense, even if it includes mistakes from the superior side.

Nobody wins a game unless the opponent errs, and most games are full of mistakes on both sides.  If you worry about winning because your opponent made a stupid move, perhaps chess is not the game for you.  Try Go - not that there are any shortage of dumb mistakes in that game, either, but if you try it you will only be annoying Go players and not us.


lol.

But there is some reality to that.  In Go if you're ahead you can afford to make many more minor errors than you can in chess.  In chess it really only takes one slip and it can completely turn the game around.