While I agree that there has been an ample amount of discussion of the topic, I lean toward the opinion that whether or not it has reached a state of "case closed" is soley determined in the mind of each reader and participant.
As for my opinion - the case is "open and shut," simple and straightforward, that the possibility in general exists that some chess.com participants may resort to cheating and if they do so, because chess.com ratings are not official, they are only doing any real damage to themselves by reinforcing a negative inclination within themselves instead of controlling and restraining it ... as Spock (of Star Trek fame) had learned to do with the dark side of his inner nature.
But the discussion seems to have petered out, dwindled away ... so I once again want to say that I've found the participation of everyone, every single one of you, lively, good for laughs and therefore also healthy ... because some studies have shown that laughter is good for the heart.
I agree with most of what you say, I too have enjoyed every single one of these responses. Some, like yours, are quite deep, intelligent, well worded and well thought out. Others are antagonistic, sarcastic, fantastic ......some are just obvious trolls trying to get a reaction out of me, very entertaining indeed !!
Thanks all for your input, I think it is safe to say given the evidence presented that FAKING a LOW rating to win is alive and well on Chess.com and it's not in fact a delusion of mine or because I suck, as one contributer so eloquently pointed out lol !!
without playing face to face it is hard to judge over the internet...what is preventing anybody to cheat using a computerized chess board to make the moves?...what fun is that to challenge the mind when the computer always wins..therefore playing online there will always be some doubt....