Why there is no book written by Magnus Carlsen?

Sort:
notmtwain
gdzen wrote:
I've been thinking about this for a while. Why there is nothing that magnus gives us other than his games.. I know it sounds strange but other chess masters try to teach people things about their understanding of chess. But nothing from magnus.. why? Is that why because of he has a natural-born ability and he has no idea how to do it? therefore he has no idea how to teach it? I wanna know why. I'm sure many people will respond as 'he has no time for that' but i'm not accepting this.. or was he asked about it, he just doesnt want it?

How many chess books have you bought?

A successful chess book sells relatively few copies.  

ABC_of_EVERYTHING
gdzen wrote:
I've been thinking about this for a while. Why there is nothing that magnus gives us other than his games.. I know it sounds strange but other chess masters try to teach people things about their understanding of chess. But nothing from magnus.. why? Is that why because of he has a natural-born ability and he has no idea how to do it? therefore he has no idea how to teach it? I wanna know why. I'm sure many people will respond as 'he has no time for that' but i'm not accepting this.. or was he asked about it, he just doesnt want it?

He teaches on an app 

illini80

As ABC_of_EVERYTHING mentions, he has an app, does lots of work on the two chess playing sites that he owns, and has started producing a video series for one of them.  My guess would be that his interest is more focused on the digital platform.  From what I've heard in interviews, books don't seem to translate into too much of a profit, so the return on time investment would be very small...especially for someone that appears to have very little free time at this point in his endeavors.  

batgirl
gdzen wrote:
Why there is nothing that magnus gives us other than his games.. 

Why do you suggest that Magnus Carlsen owes you or anyone else anything?

Monie49
He is making money on the digital platform!
Welcome to 2020.
IsDannyOhKaye

"Is that why because of he has a natural-born ability"

These "natural born" apples are not grown far from the tree.

 

1. Polgar sisters had their father Laszlo.

2. Wolfgang Mozart had Leopald

3. Paul Morphy had Alonzo

4. Ben had Jerry (wait a minute, I am just hungry for ice cream, scratch that)

5. Wynton, Branford (and the others) Marsalis had Ellis

6. Michael, Tito, etc... Jackson had Joe

7. Bobby, Peter, and Greg had Michael

8. Cindy, Jan, and Marcia had Carol

9. Alice called the butcher guy daddy

10. Doogie Howser had Henrik

MorphysMayhem
batgirl wrote:
gdzen wrote:
Why there is nothing that magnus gives us other than his games.. 

Why do you suggest that Magnus Carlsen owes you or anyone else anything?

That, and he is making real money winning tourneys, modeling, and endorsing product s. When he is an old hack he can make money writing and selling chess books. But that will be later in his career.

Caesar49bc

Magnus Carlsen let's his record speak for itself.

Also, he has his own app for teaching chess. I'd say that's way more than he could fit into several books, and it's interactive.

IsDannyOhKaye
Caesar49bc wrote:

Also, he has his own app for teaching chess.

 

Are the ages at set levels? They haven't been changed over the years? So, if you played the same line and won in 2018, you would still win in 2020?

GM_chess_player
IsDannyOhKaye wrote:
Caesar49bc wrote:

Also, he has his own app for teaching chess.

 

Are the ages at set levels? They haven't been changed over the years? So, if you played the same line and won in 2018, you would still win in 2020?

I guess. I mean, every year, when Magnus grows older, they make a new level. Passing Magnus age 20 is itself a challenge.

IsDannyOhKaye
GM_chess_player wrote:
IsDannyOhKaye wrote:
Caesar49bc wrote:

Also, he has his own app for teaching chess.

 

Are the ages at set levels? They haven't been changed over the years? So, if you played the same line and won in 2018, you would still win in 2020?

I guess. I mean, every year, when Magnus grows older, they make a new level. Passing Magnus age 20 is itself a challenge.

 

But they don't change Magnus at 10 ever?

IsDannyOhKaye

I am going to write a book and title it, "Does Magnus have any other hobbies?"

leejune34

poop is funny

BlackKaweah

What would he write? “Play Drawing Chess!”

IsDannyOhKaye
leejune34 wrote:

poop is funny

 

Don't forget the wee.

Typewriter44
gdzen wrote:
I've been thinking about this for a while. Why there is nothing that magnus gives us other than his games.. I know it sounds strange but other chess masters try to teach people things about their understanding of chess. But nothing from magnus.. why? Is that why because of he has a natural-born ability and he has no idea how to do it? therefore he has no idea how to teach it? I wanna know why. I'm sure many people will respond as 'he has no time for that' but i'm not accepting this.. or was he asked about it, he just doesnt want it?

He makes more money from playing chess, and even if he did want to write books, he might not be a good writer. Just because you're good at playing doesn't mean you're good at coaching or writing books.

MorphysMayhem
leejune34 wrote:

poop is funny

now there is a comment we can all finally agree on! thanking you for reminding us there is much that unites us, even though there a some things that divide us.

brianchesscake

Bobby Fischer did not actually write his own books. He had a shadow writer who would endorse his brand and make money off his name, and Fischer wasn't happy about the deal but he never explicitly told them to get lost.

Caesar49bc
IsDannyOhKaye wrote:
Caesar49bc wrote:

Also, he has his own app for teaching chess.

 

Are the ages at set levels? They haven't been changed over the years? So, if you played the same line and won in 2018, you would still win in 2020?

I've never used Magnus Carlsen's app, but I know it's primarly used to learn better chess. Also, I think he run's contests or something on it, where the winner gets to play Magnus Carlsen.

That's pretty much all I know.

IsDannyOhKaye

Maybe it's like war. North Korea isn't publishing a book on how to destroy the USA. That would just give away their secrets. The Kim family is very smart. We can't even get in a third Bush into office or Hillary Clinton. They successfully got 3 people of the same family.