Good vs Bad?

Sort:
Avatar of Viau_A

I would like to know what is the diffrences between the "good" bishop and the "bad" bishop, or knight or whatever....  and how do you know witch is witch.

I ask this because when I look at gm games with comments, they often refer to good and bad pieces. What do the comentators mean by "good" and "bad". 

Avatar of shadowslayer
no Idea what your talking about
Avatar of abcdefg123456aaaaa
a good bishop is one that has an open file that it can travel on, preferably without being in killed in the process. a bad bishop is one that is trapped and cannot be moved, like two pawns obstructing the bishops pathway. the same definition that be applied to the other pieces as well.
Avatar of Graw81
A bad bishop is a bishop for example that is on black sqaures, and its central pawns are also on black sqaures. The reverse is for a good bishop. A bad bishop is not neccessaryily a 'bad' piece because it may be 'active'. just read reassess your chess by silman and learn for yourself. its fun and easy =)
Avatar of Viau_A

GM Vallejo Pons wins XVII Pamplona International

Move 25

Just slowly improving the position of his pieces. Now the bishop can go to h5 at some moment. A mistake would have been 25. Bc4 trading off his good bishop for black's bad bishop

 

It totally makes sense now.

reassess your chess by silman , ll look it up thank you.

Avatar of KingLeopold
Viau_A wrote:

I would like to know what is the diffrences between the "good" bishop and the "bad" bishop...

 


 My friend and coach GM Rashit Ziatdinov says there is no such thing as bad bishops, just bad owners.

Remember, "The general in charge of your army is not the king. It is You! The king is just a wooden piece without any brains." -GM Ziatdinov 


Avatar of Charlie91

Simply put, a bad bishop (or any piece) does not have any purpose, like a bishop that is blocked by his own forces (see bishop in diagram); a good bishop does have a purpose, and has good mobility.  But this should not be permanent--can be changed.  One good example of bad pieces is a smothered mate (king imprisoned by own forces).  In the diagram, the queen, knight and pawn (technically not a piece) are all bad pieces...  Yell

RetGuvvie98 (see following post), I've modified the diagram appropriate for your comment.Wink