Hikaru Nakamura disqualified for having a phone near him during his online game! - Chess Forums - Page 4

TRAP4MOUSE · 2021-10-17T04:39:26-07:00

New drama for the chess world :) When rules become chess traps that even Grandmasters fall into!Hi all Disclaimer: I may have all the facts totally wrong. Please message me and I can edit the blog as appropriate. Please read at your own risk. By scrolling down, you accept the risk of all facts here

PerpetualPatzer123

Oct 18, 2021

0

#61

royalknight101 wrote:

AunTheKnight wrote:

royalknight101 wrote:

AunTheKnight wrote:

royalknight101 wrote:

i mean it is hikaru, he never cheats and same with magnus given their history in the elite

It’d be unfair just because they’re famous to allow exceptions.

it doesnt involve famous but just records, why would the #1 chess streamer and major impacter in boosting online chess cheat? when you look at it this way, its illogical for him to be disqualified at all and same with vidit as drawn positions should be offered ❤️

Exactly. Influential and famous. Impacting chess… streamer.

Once again, making exceptions like that is just unjust (see what I did there?).

again tell yourself this? would magnus carlsen ever cheat?

But we could say that for any player.

Like… a friend on Chess.com.

gmngana29

Oct 18, 2021

0

#62

royalknight101 wrote:

AunTheKnight wrote:

royalknight101 wrote:

AunTheKnight wrote:

royalknight101 wrote:

i mean it is hikaru, he never cheats and same with magnus given their history in the elite

It’d be unfair just because they’re famous to allow exceptions.

it doesnt involve famous but just records, why would the #1 chess streamer and major impacter in boosting online chess cheat? when you look at it this way, its illogical for him to be disqualified at all and same with vidit as drawn positions should be offered ❤️

Exactly. Influential and famous. Impacting chess… streamer.

Once again, making exceptions like that is just unjust (see what I did there?).

again tell yourself this? would magnus carlsen ever cheat?

Would established GM 2630 Tigran Petrosian cheat?

Making exceptions for GMs and titled players is unfair. WC and top streamer too. It is like in society if a celebrity speeds on the street "do you think this celebrity will kill someone?"

PerpetualPatzer123

Oct 18, 2021

0

#63

royalknight101 wrote:

gmngana29 wrote:

royalknight101 wrote:

AunTheKnight wrote:

royalknight101 wrote:

AunTheKnight wrote:

royalknight101 wrote:

i mean it is hikaru, he never cheats and same with magnus given their history in the elite

It’d be unfair just because they’re famous to allow exceptions.

it doesnt involve famous but just records, why would the #1 chess streamer and major impacter in boosting online chess cheat? when you look at it this way, its illogical for him to be disqualified at all and same with vidit as drawn positions should be offered ❤️

Exactly. Influential and famous. Impacting chess… streamer.

Once again, making exceptions like that is just unjust (see what I did there?).

again tell yourself this? would magnus carlsen ever cheat?

Would established GM 2630 Tigran Petrosian cheat?

Making exceptions for GMs and titled players is unfair. WC and top streamer too. It is like in society if a celebrity speeds on the street "do you think this celebrity will kill someone?"

tigran was a cheap bozo who got caught, think about it if magnus and hikaru have played here for more than a decade and never got into fair play violations, what makes you think they are cheaters? hikaru is literally the icon for the site, what would he gain by disgracing chess as he is the best american player and the best streamer in our era for the time being

Taylor Swift is an American icon. What if she does drugs or something? Dismiss her? “She’s famous, she would never.”

PerpetualPatzer123

Oct 18, 2021

0

#64

royalknight101 wrote:

AunTheKnight wrote:

royalknight101 wrote:

gmngana29 wrote:

royalknight101 wrote:

AunTheKnight wrote:

royalknight101 wrote:

AunTheKnight wrote:

royalknight101 wrote:

i mean it is hikaru, he never cheats and same with magnus given their history in the elite

It’d be unfair just because they’re famous to allow exceptions.

it doesnt involve famous but just records, why would the #1 chess streamer and major impacter in boosting online chess cheat? when you look at it this way, its illogical for him to be disqualified at all and same with vidit as drawn positions should be offered ❤️

Exactly. Influential and famous. Impacting chess… streamer.

Once again, making exceptions like that is just unjust (see what I did there?).

again tell yourself this? would magnus carlsen ever cheat?

Would established GM 2630 Tigran Petrosian cheat?

Making exceptions for GMs and titled players is unfair. WC and top streamer too. It is like in society if a celebrity speeds on the street "do you think this celebrity will kill someone?"

tigran was a cheap bozo who got caught, think about it if magnus and hikaru have played here for more than a decade and never got into fair play violations, what makes you think they are cheaters? hikaru is literally the icon for the site, what would he gain by disgracing chess as he is the best american player and the best streamer in our era for the time being

Taylor Swift is an American icon. What if she does drugs or something? Dismiss her? “She’s famous, she would never.”

your not looking at the logic here, just cause someone is famous doesnt mean they cant be punished. there is just lots of evidence which make it extremely hard and not convincing that hikaru would ever cheat. you are comparing drugs with being a cheater and that makes no sense, suggesting she only autotunes and doesnt sing like she sounds would be better.

One reason I hate pop is that no one uses their real voice. Autotune isn’t cheating. Just dumb. We’re discussing prohibitions here.

There’s a lot of things that say she wouldn’t do something illegal, but there’s always a chance. Sure, Carlsen and Nakamura have lots of influence, but that doesn’t necessarily prevent them from doing anything illegal. In fact, influence may even increase the chance.

Anonymous_Dragon

Oct 18, 2021

0

#65

AunTheKnight wrote:

Anonymous_Dragon wrote:

Bruh it's been 32 comments . And not one person has had the intellectual capacity to respond with something that adds worth to the discussion . All I see is "sad" , "he didn't cheat" , "okay" .

Pathetic

Sorry about that. I just didn’t know what to say.

I personally think that those rules are simply unneeded. At least, at the calibre they are in.

I think they are reasonable considering the extent to which people might go in order to cheat

Anonymous_Dragon

Oct 18, 2021

0

#66

royalknight101 wrote:

AunTheKnight wrote:

royalknight101 wrote:

i mean it is hikaru, he never cheats and same with magnus given their history in the elite

It’d be unfair just because they’re famous to allow exceptions.

it doesnt involve famous but just records, why would the #1 chess streamer and major impacter in boosting online chess cheat? when you look at it this way, its illogical for him to be disqualified at all and same with vidit as drawn positions should be offered ❤️

If course it is very unlikely that these influential people would cheat. But it's not impossible. And rules are rules . Can't have exceptions for anyone

zes0460

Oct 18, 2021

0

#67

he doesnt need an engine

Stil1

Oct 18, 2021

0

#68

Here's the moment it happened (for those who haven't seen it):

Twitch Clip - GMHikaru - Phone Interruption

To me, it's a non-issue. His phone rang. He was annoyed by the interruption. He tapped his phone to mute it.

Not sure why the arbiter didn't simply issue him a warning for it. But it is what it is.

TRAP4MOUSE

Oct 18, 2021

0

#69

gmngana29 wrote:

AunTheKnight wrote:

Anonymous_Dragon wrote:

Bruh it's been 32 comments . And not one person has had the intellectual capacity to respond with something that adds worth to the discussion . All I see is "sad" , "he didn't cheat" , "okay" .

Pathetic

Sorry about that. I just didn’t know what to say.

I personally think that those rules are simply unneeded. At least, at the calibre they are in.

Are they? He said himself, rules are rules. He's popular of course, so a lot of his fans will hit back at it, but I think especially with cheating in online chess, that these rules are very reasonable.

The phone was on: potentially someone could be texting him moves, or the amount of times the phone vibrates is the move to make. Of course that isn't going to happen with Hikaru, but high profile examples like that have happened.

True

TRAP4MOUSE

Oct 18, 2021

0

#70

zes0460 wrote:

he doesnt need an engine

Hikaru not cheated but he kept his mobile near him

Immaculate_Slayer

Oct 18, 2021

0

#71

Hikaru is noob

TRAP4MOUSE

Oct 18, 2021

0

#72

Stil1 wrote:

Here's the moment it happened (for those who haven't seen it):

Twitch Clip - GMHikaru - Phone Interruption

To me, it's a non-issue. His phone rang. He was annoyed by the interruption. He tapped his phone to mute it.

Not sure why the arbiter didn't simply issue him a warning for it. But it is what it is.

TRAP4MOUSE

Oct 18, 2021

0

#73

fattom47 wrote:

HE WAS TEXTING ME ASKING FOR HELP. THIS IS MY DOING AND I AM PROUD

TRAP4MOUSE

Oct 18, 2021

0

#74

?

Anonymous_Dragon

Oct 18, 2021

0

#75

Immaculate_Slayer wrote:

Hikaru is noob

Could beat you and your sibling blindfolded simultaneously

TRAP4MOUSE

Oct 18, 2021

0

#76

Anonymous_Dragon wrote:

Immaculate_Slayer wrote:

Hikaru is noob

Could beat you and your sibling blindfolded simultaneously

:troll

TRAP4MOUSE

Oct 18, 2021

0

#77

Anonymous_Dragon wrote:

Immaculate_Slayer wrote:

Hikaru is noob

Could beat you and your sibling blindfolded simultaneously

His sibling could be magnus

danisanchess

Oct 18, 2021

0

#78

Anonymous_Dragon escribió:

Bruh it's been 32 comments . And not one person has had the intellectual capacity to respond with something that adds worth to the discussion . All I see is "sad" , "he didn't cheat" , "okay" .

Pathetic

bruh you should look at the mirror

TRAP4MOUSE

Oct 18, 2021

0

#79

-_-

TRAP4MOUSE

Oct 18, 2021

0

#80

danisanchess wrote:

Anonymous_Dragon escribió:

Bruh it's been 32 comments . And not one person has had the intellectual capacity to respond with something that adds worth to the discussion . All I see is "sad" , "he didn't cheat" , "okay" .

Pathetic

bruh you should look at the mirror