How good would Paul Morphy do against today's chessplayers?

Sort:
Avatar of Pierre_123

Say Morphy time travels to today's society and enters into a chess tournament where he plays against a number of GMs, IMs and Masters.  How would he do?  I would like to consider a few scenarios:

Scenario 1: Morphy is given one year prep time to catch up (including training with top current players) before entering tournament. 

Scenario 2: Morphy has no prep time, but his opponents cannot tell who he is.

Scenario 3: No catch up time; his opponents can recognize Morphy at the beginning of the tournament but no opportunity to study his games / prep against him specifically.

Scenario 4: Morphy has no catch up time; his opponents not only know who they are up against, but have 2 months to prepare and study his games before tournament (very unfair odds, I know).

Avatar of notmtwain
Pierre_123 wrote:

Say Morphy time travels to today's society and enters into a chess tournament where he plays against a number of GMs, IMs and Masters.  How would he do?  I would like to consider a few scenarios:

Scenario 1: Morphy is given one year prep time to catch up (including training with top current players) before entering tournament. 

Scenario 2: Morphy has no prep time, but his opponents cannot tell who he is.

Scenario 3: No catch up time; his opponents can recognize Morphy at the beginning of the tournament but no opportunity to study his games / prep against him specifically.

Scenario 4: Morphy has no catch up time; his opponents not only know who they are up against, but have 2 months to prepare and study his games before tournament (very unfair odds, I know).

https://www.chess.com/forum/view/general/fischer-s-own-thoughts-on-gms-competing-across-history