Black definitely has the advantage in that position, but it's not a clear win. Positional advantages are the most subject to change.
Hypermodern Theory SOLVED! (part 2)
Sort:
I'll accept your challenge, but i don't know what you'll gain. I'm a 1330, and your a 2000+, So if i lose it's not going to because of the opening, it's going to be because of tactics and mid game strategy.
Well JhanasEcstasy (or should I say mikex22) , I see you created this new ID to bump both these posts.
and WHY do you even KNOW both posts were commented on? and why do you CARE enough to respond to a bump? is your ego that fragile that it needs mending already? I said it before, I'm not Jhanas, and you my friend need to get a social life. People who religiously stalk others only to comment on such things in order to demonstrate...whatever the heck it is you think you're demonstrating, leave much to be desired in a person
I made those posts simultaneously something like 10 hours ago when a totally new account bumped both posts at the same time without saying anything. (If he's your friend, that's great, not very chatty though is he lol).
The internet doesn't give any tone of voice so you would know, but I it was more playful than you would think... I didn't think the site bans users for multiple accounts when I made the post (except for when using to cheat in tournaments etc) but obviously they would which makes my post a lot more coarse than I meant it to be.
[edit, oh and I read your comment on the other post, posting in two at once like this is a pain 
glad there's no hard feelings]
Some people dug deep into the depths of their ego yesterday and thought they were being clever, funny, or perhaps, dare I say, cool. (see this link for details http://www.chess.com/forum/view/general/hypermodern-theory-solved )
As a consequence for lacking a sense of humor, the following two players are socially doomed to play out the joke opening in a real game against me (I've put the moves down as the game title so they don't forget.)
If either of them should deviate from the "main line" at any time, I'll gladly accept that as a forfeit to my superior social and chess genius.
The following two are those foolish enough to act cooler than me. Hope to post the game links soon when (IF) they accept my challenges.
RainbowRising
United Kingdom
Member Points: 279
You are an idiot. Not only is your point incredibley stupid, but you tried to be funny by saying 'using only one piece', and you used both knights.
Assassin2142
United States
Member Points: 223
Black would easly win this game. I could beat someone easy if they just did that