Of course ...a6 is a losing blunder as it loses a pawn for nothing after Bxc6. The 35 % is meaningless if it's only isolating a small number of games.
Say for example there were 10 games with 1.e3 and white scored 0% (just using these numbers for an example). Then after you enter the moves 1.e3 e6 2.e4 e5 you transpose back into a main position where White obviously scores decently.
It does sound like you need to reset your search boosters on chessbase if your database is a decent size (several millon games) and that's all you're getting. (reference database, right click/delete search booster, right click again/create search booster)
LOL... I obviously didn't spend any time looking at the position. I was looking at the statistics. Oops.
Nothing personal against you, but this is a perfect illustration on the reliance of technology, and not actually using your own abilities to think things through. I think we are all guilty of this to some extent.
Lopez is still great. His stuff has been very helpful.