The truth about Dr. Frank Brady and Fischer

Sort:
Avatar of Roo_2_Unlimited
TheRealGMBobbyFish wrote:
robbie_1969 wrote:
  Its 1:28 AM in Glasgow and I need a beer to numb the pain of reading your reproaches!

Whiskey.  It's only 8:30PM in New York.  We can reproach all night.

Whiskey is the Irish spelling, in Scotland we spell it Whisky.

Avatar of odisea777
robbie_1969 wrote:
ab121705 wrote:
Darth_Algar wrote:

"Madness", "insane", "lunatic", "crazy" are not claims of mental illness and they are not medical terms. They're simply prejoritive, like calling someone "daft". "Schizophrenia", "Bipolar Disorder", "Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder", "Borderline Personality Disorder", "Dissociative Identity Disorder" are examples of a medical diagnosis of mental illness. Frank Brady makes no such claims in his book. Now stop being daft and read the book before criticising it or its author. 

+1 good post

No its a rather weak and beggarly semantic argument which does not stand up to scrutiny and is demonstrably false for if the proposer is to be believed Brady was simply using it as a derogatory term for Fischer akin to Fischer being 'daft' his own words, despite Bradys own evidence that he had a book full of psychological evidence and that in his first book he described being in Fischers presence as in the presence of genius.  Thus his argument is illogical, unreasonable and does not stand up to scrutiny.

 

talk about a descent into madness..

Avatar of Roo_2_Unlimited
 

talk about a descent into madness..

Its me ab121705, Bobby, they think I'm dead but i been hiding out in a remote church in Iceland so the Americans don't kidnap me and send me back to those Japanese jails where all the prison guards are gay!  The crows bring me food and the latest snippets from TWIC!

Avatar of odisea777

I thought you were done posting in this thread a couple of days ago

Avatar of TheRealGMBobbyFish
robbie_1969 wrote:

Whiskey is the Irish spelling, in Scotland we spell it Whisky.

Good to know.

Avatar of TheRealGMBobbyFish
robbie_1969 wrote:
TheRealGMBobbyFish wrote:
robbie_1969 wrote:

I will read the book and subject my hypothesis to falsification.

Shouldn't be hard to do since you hypothesis is based on nothing deeper than the title of the book. 

If you read the thread you will see that your statement is demonstrably false. 

I have read the thread.  You seem to be pretty clear that you haven't read Brady's work and the only review you posted disagreed with your position.  What then have you based your hypothesis on?

Avatar of Scannerman

Isnt the ACP president Israeli?  And the Fide president claimed to be abducted by aliens, but its Bobby fischer whos crazy because he made observations. But the FIDE president is a multi millionare so its ok to talk to aliens, this is the dude who beat karpov and kasporov for FIDE president, this is the shit that drives people mad like Fischer. This is the stuff that need to be talked about and repeated loudly if people choose not to listen, ofcourse the domesticated blind sheep would think the out spoken observent man to be "insain" the nail head that sticks out gets beat back down.

The current FEDI president is not jewish btw just rich.

Avatar of Darth_Algar

Thinking you were abducted by aliens, while a sign that you're maybe not all there, is pretty harmless, a bit amusing even. Calling for the slaughter of millions of people is repugnant.

Avatar of Scannerman

Darth_Algar what about the acctual killing of millions of native americans? thats not repugnant? if you listened to Fischers rant you would have heard the reasoning behind his madness. 

Avatar of Darth_Algar
Scannerman wrote:

Darth_Algar what about the acctual killing of millions of native americans? thats not repugnant? if you listened to Fischers rant you would have heard the reasoning behind his madness. 

Yup, exactly. I find Fischer's hate-filling rantings against Jews abhorrent, so obviously I support the slaughter of Native Americans.

Avatar of Scannerman

when theres smoke there ussualy fire.

Avatar of TheRealGMBobbyFish
Scannerman wrote:

Isnt the ACP president Israeli?  And the Fide president claimed to be abducted by aliens, but its Bobby fischer whos crazy because he made observations. ...

 

This is not all or nothing.  It is not mentally challenging or even hypocritical to observe that Fischer most probably was mad and find has rants greatly offensive while still believing FIDE is corrupt and Governments past treatment of First Nations people as bordering criminal.  Fischer may have a point on some or even many topics.  It doesn't mean he wasn't nuts.  I can play 1.e4 without believing in a Jewish conspiracy.  It's easy.

Avatar of Roo_2_Unlimited

I just want to say to all my detractors (you know who you are), that i will pick up Bradys tabloid from my local library today and when i read it i will offer up my evaluations for peer review and the falsification of my findings.  All i can say is he better have empirical evidence for his claims otherwise its gonna get roasty toasty for you! Tongue Out

Avatar of Tal1949

It would not surprise me if Bobby suffered from something as simple as a 'anxiety disorder,' his problems in 72-75 certainly indicated that. It was close call that Bobby even turned up against Spassky, and by the Karpov days there was no chance of Bobby showing up. 

Of course years later the tunnel he went down was far deeper than that. In the end he twisted reality and refused to see even a simple truth. Even his renal problems could be fixed if he trusted other people.

Avatar of Benzodiazepine

I suffer from anxiety disorder, too and perhaps ADHD.

Two seemingly competing disorders.

Tal, are you a psychiatrist?!

Avatar of Roo_2_Unlimited

I will psycoanalyse you, lie down on my couch and tell me how you feel today.

Avatar of odisea777
robbie_1969 wrote:

I just want to say to all my detractors (you know who you are), that i will pick up Bradys tabloid from my local library today and when i read it i will offer up my evaluations for peer review and the falsification of my findings.  All i can say is he better have empirical evidence for his claims otherwise its gonna get roasty toasty for you!

nobody gives a crap; I just wiped my ### with your last post

Avatar of TheRealGMBobbyFish
robbie_1969 wrote:

I will psycoanalyse you, lie down on my couch and tell me how you feel today.

Will you really?  Read a few covers of Freud.  Maybe 'The Interpretation of Dreams'?  You really are impressive.

Avatar of TheRealGMBobbyFish
robbie_1969 wrote:

I just want to say to all my detractors (you know who you are), that i will pick up Bradys tabloid from my local library today and when i read it i will offer up my evaluations for peer review and the falsification of my findings.  All i can say is he better have empirical evidence for his claims otherwise its gonna get roasty toasty for you!

It's cute when you use 'falsification' and 'peer review' in such a way that makes it obvious you have no idea what they even are.  Good luck with your 'empirical evidence.'  I am sure it will be an painfully entertaining review.

Avatar of Roo_2_Unlimited
TheRealGMBobbyFish wrote:
robbie_1969 wrote:

I will psycoanalyse you, lie down on my couch and tell me how you feel today.

Will you really?  Read a few covers of Freud.  Maybe 'The Interpretation of Dreams'?  You really are impressive.

I was merely jesting, any sane and rational person with even a smattering of discernment would readily come to that conclusion themselves.  Perhaps if you were not so assuming you might just save yourself from jumping to erroneous conclusions in future, although given your present proclivity for sucking the humanity from people texts with your gelid tentacles I don't hold out much hope for you.