Top 10 19th century players

Sort:
Avatar of shakedaspear
batgirl wrote:

(a persuasive and well-researched post)

Avatar of fabelhaft

"Steinitz had an even record against Adolph Anderssen. Paul Morphy's record against Anderssen was +12 -3 =2. He would have EASILY beaten Steinitz. Just FYI"

Kasparov scored 16-0 against Shirov, Kramnik had a minus score against Shirov in 2000. Kasparov would easily have beaten Kramnik in 2000, at least until the match actually was played.

Avatar of Senna-Jawa

1. E.Lasker
2. Morphy
3. Steinitz
4. Anderssen
5. Zukertort
6. Chigorin
7. Pillsbury
8. Winawer

Avatar of Senna-Jawa

Steinitz was OLDER than Morphy. Yes, Morphy was YOUNGER than Steinitz. (Surprised?)

Avatar of darkunorthodox88
MorphyFan81 wrote:

"Morphy was the greatest player of his time and would've been beaten by the five players rated above him". 

   Steinitz had an even record against Adolph Anderssen. Paul Morphy's record against Anderssen was +12 -3 =2. He would have EASILY beaten Steinitz. Just FYI.

i dont think you can do chessmetric math that easily. its not A>B>C therefore A>C

Avatar of Pilot_Xtreme

reviving from the dead again...

Avatar of Pilot_Xtreme
fabelhaft wrote:

"Steinitz had an even record against Adolph Anderssen. Paul Morphy's record against Anderssen was +12 -3 =2. He would have EASILY beaten Steinitz. Just FYI"

 

Kasparov scored 16-0 against Shirov, Kramnik had a minus score against Shirov in 2000. Kasparov would easily have beaten Kramnik in 2000, at least until the match actually was played.

yeah