Top 5 Chess Players of ALL TIME (opinion/debate/controversial?)

Sort:
Avatar of BrilliantCheckMaterX

1. Magnus!!

2. Bobby Fischer

3. Judit Polgar

4. Hikaru Nakamura

5. Javokhir Sindarov

Avatar of MRayelABC

I do not know I just know MRayelABC is number 1

Avatar of Skullie1gk

Where is MRayelABC on this list? He is definitely a top 5

Avatar of Chesswhitebelt
Sindarov and Nakamura making the all time list is wild #41 😭
Avatar of chessblackbelt

Fischer took inspiration from Morphy, but that also doesn’t mean he’s worse than Morphy.

Avatar of DoYouLikeCurry
chesssblackbelt wrote:

I find it ridiculous how people can have capablanca higher than Lasker when they played in the same sort of time period and Lasker dominated

Think it’s probably due to the impact capa had on certain aspects of the game… like no one came close to his endgame skills again for decades and decades

Avatar of chesssblackbelt

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_1924_chess_tournament

Lasker was 55 years old in this tournament and still finished ahead of prime capablanca lmao

Avatar of MaetsNori
chesssblackbelt wrote:

I find it ridiculous how people can have capablanca higher than Lasker when they played in the same sort of time period and Lasker dominated

It's probably because Capablanca defeated Lasker so convincingly in their WC match. Although to be fair to Lasker, he was past his prime then, and Capa was 20 years younger.

Avatar of thereturnofthesnowfox

1. Karpov
2. Capablanca
3. Kasparov
4. Tal
5. Carlsen

Avatar of manoli05

magnus

Avatar of nhatminh4a123

its so good

Avatar of Jayson-Zions

1. Kasparov ( GOAT, INSANE ELO WITH INSANE OPPONENTS, ALWAYS 2700+ elo for around 30 YRS)

2. Magnus ( STOCKFISH PREPERATION, INSANE ACCURACY, MULTI FORMAT)

3.Capa (INSNAE ACCURACY, INSANE OPPONENTS, INSNAE EVEN THOUGH HE DOSENT HAVE PERKS OTHERS DID)

4. Fischer ( INSANE ACCURACY, MOST SUPREME SHORT REIGN)

5. Kramniik/Vishy (INSNAE ACCURACY, RAINED SUPREME FOR MOST YEARS, INSANE OPPONENTS EVERY YEAR)

Avatar of MaetsNori
fhckusfvd-ff wrote:

2. Magnus ( STOCKFISH PREPERATION, INSANE ACCURACY, MULTI FORMAT)

Magnus isn't really a Stockfish prep guy. He glances at engines lines, shrugs, then does his own thing.

Avatar of Jayson-Zions

Some people like Tal (At peak was absolutely insane), Lasker ( Most years supreme but no as hard as opponents as Capa so he dosent have something ‘special’ but I wouldn’t be mad if you put him in list) or current sgm+( people with engine prep 2800+ elo) could be put on list to Tom people ahead of their time too (morphy, alkheine etc,)

Avatar of Jayson-Zions
MaetsNori wrote:
fhckusfvd-ff wrote:

2. Magnus ( STOCKFISH PREPERATION, INSANE ACCURACY, MULTI FORMAT)

Magnus isn't really a Stockfish prep guy. He glances at engines lines, shrugs, then does his own thing.

Yeah but he grew up learning in the era of engines so he has some knowledge compared to like Kasparov and capa

Avatar of Jayson-Zions

If Magnus is insane for more years he would probably take Capablanca s place and more years after that maybe Kasparov too

Avatar of MaetsNori
fhckusfvd-ff wrote:
MaetsNori wrote:
fhckusfvd-ff wrote:

2. Magnus ( STOCKFISH PREPERATION, INSANE ACCURACY, MULTI FORMAT)

Magnus isn't really a Stockfish prep guy. He glances at engines lines, shrugs, then does his own thing.

Yeah but he grew up learning in the era of engines so he has some knowledge compared to like Kasparov and capa

Well ...

Magnus was nearly 2800 before Stockfish was even invented ...

He's more the old-school generation. He reached GM by playing a lot over-the-board, training with coaches, and reading a ton of books.

He definitely has a lot of Stockfish knowledge nowadays (as everyone does) - but it wasn't how he learned.

Avatar of chesssblackbelt
MaetsNori wrote:
chesssblackbelt wrote:

I find it ridiculous how people can have capablanca higher than Lasker when they played in the same sort of time period and Lasker dominated

It's probably because Capablanca defeated Lasker so convincingly in their WC match. Although to be fair to Lasker, he was past his prime then, and Capa was 20 years younger.

Yeah that was prime Capablanca against a 55 year old Lasker it's not fair. Lasker was world champion for the longest time in history

Avatar of Jayson-Zions

Capablanca is also statistically better

Avatar of Jayson-Zions

By a little bit still