@irontiger I could say the wild troll comment seems like a case of projection as nearly every uninformed criticism toward strangers falls into that category, but it's too easy. You're pitching beach balls.
Well, if you seriously believe that the Scandinavian is busted because you claim it so, you belong to this thread : http://www.chess.com/forum/view/chess-openings (see norelyer's posts). As hard as I hate the Scandinavian, I am forced to recognize it's not busted yet.
Academic, definitely - but also interesting and fun (for at least some) to debate.