Which castle pawn to move when queen threatens checkmate?

Sort:
the_last_rites

Do you move g6 or h6? I know it depends on position of other pieces but what do you find better? 


the_last_rites

ps. this is not a game scenario. I have just used the pieces I want to focus on. 

the_last_rites
coneheadzombie wrote:

h6, obviously.

 

That's what I want to know. Why is that obvious? Why not g6?

MrEdCollins

I assume you mean 1...g6 or 1...f5.  After 1...h6, White still has a mate in 1.

It really depends upon the specific position.  But to answer your question, it's probably g6 more often than f5, assuming this is Black's only resource.  Moving the f-pawn probably will weaken the b2-g8 diagonal too much.

alayton88

h6 is so strong it scares the queen away from the qh7 mate... duh.

The_Aggressive_Bee

h6 won't do you any good in this position.

ivandh

I think you should probably make the move that stops checkmate. I'm no expert though.

fabelhaft

There's no need to move any pawn since the strong Re8 prevents Qxh7+

xxvalakixx

It depends. You should play g6 if the weakness of the dark squares is not important. (You have a dark squared bishop, or your opponent does not have one) You should play f5, if it is important to not weak the dark squares. h6 does not change anything, it is still a mate after h6.

the_last_rites

sorry I got the position wrong. I played OTB in the evening and didn't remember the position. Yeah I can see after h6 it's still mate. Here is the actual position.

The position was like this. We both had more pieces which I don't remember.

x-5058622868

The example would be better if you had the queen on the h-file.

the_last_rites
Sunshiny wrote:

The example would be better if you had the queen on the h-file.

Tongue Out that's what I was aiming for.

Mila_Kunis

In your example h6 gives your opponent a mate in one. That should solve the problem :D

If you switch the position of queen and bishop however it's another story. Usually as a rule of thumb g6 weakens the dark sqares while h6 makes you more vulnerable to pawn pushes on the king side.

But as you already mentioned there is no such thing as a "general rule" in chess, so it's always better to calculate than trying to exclusively think in patterns.

fabelhaft

In general I'd prefer h6 in such positions if black is without dark squared bishop. After g6 there's a bad hole on h6 for the white queen.

the_last_rites
[COMMENT DELETED]
ivandh

I think h6 is preferable in general.

ealdor

h6 doesn't help much, as the White queen can just move to f5, and g6 will have to be played anyway.