Well, I've heard that the thread should stay locked. It was said that the thread stated up front a requirement that posts stay away from politics, cursing and religion but failed to moderate posts that did not meet that standard.
I did moderate some of the worse posts. And there is no reason my thread should have been locked without a warning.
i think justbefair is correct here. it did not appear you were stern enough evaluating posts and warning others that went over the line you stated in your op.
for example, i have a topic about guns that i dedicated to another member here. a topic that *some* might see as a vehicle to express their political views. i made it clear in the op i would do as much as i could to make sure the topic was not locked due to their tos violations. if you were to read through it, you'll see i was forced to slap some on the wrist for posts that could get it locked. worst of all, i had to block a few, and i abhor that.
if you start a topic where you know some might post about religion/politics, better make sure you moderate it yourself with more of a heavy hand than you currently have, even if that is not your nature.
Good luck.
I mean, it's all very well to quote rules but they are meaningless unless examples of what is ok or not are to hand. Otherwise it's a matter of interpretation and personal opinion as to what's incorrect. That's why Sludgey has a good case.
Chess.com is not a Democracy with the ability to appeal to a higher court. Chess.com is a business and they can run it any way they desire; they are a Dictatorship with all power and authority to run the platform in any manner they desire; they can do whatever they want and Sludgey has no recourse. Other than what Sludgey posted, I have no idea what they said or did, but someone at Chess.com pulled the plug, and that's that.
No, they can only do what they are allowed to. They can't just lock a thread because they feel like it.
Okay. You win. Let me know when and why they unlock your Thread.