A Bobby Fischer Conundrum: Fischer vs Matthai (Montreal 1956)

Sort:
Startropic1

In 1956 Bobby Fischer played a game vs Hans Matthai in a tournament in Montreal, that ended up being a 108-move marathon ending in a draw.  Apparently after analyzing the game later, Fischer found a way for white (Fischer) to win, but this "win" is not recorded.  I've not found this solution myself, does anyone else care to give it a go? Can anyone find a win for white?

To quote the book Endgame:

"That night, in a deep but restless sleep, a dream came to him and the position appeared over and over again - seemingly hundreds of times. Just before waking, the solution came to Bobby as a kind of apparition. There WAS a win there!

Bobby woke and sat bolt upright. "I've got it!" he said aloud, not knowing that anyone else was in the room. [text deleted] "I knew I should have won!" he fairly screamed."

Here's the final position.  The last move was Qb5+ by Fisher. Black to move.

Here's the full notation of the game:
1. e4 c5 2. Nf3 d6 3. d4 cd4 4. Nd4 g6 5. Nc3 Bg7 6. Be3 Nf67. f3 Nc6 8. Qd2 O-O 9. Bc4 Bd7 10. h4 Rc8 11. Bb3 Qa512. O-O-O Nh5 13. g4 Nd4 14. Bd4 Bd4 15. Qd4 Nf4 16. Kb1Ne6 17. Qd2 Rfe8 18. f4 Nc5 19. h5 Nb3 20. ab3 Bg421. Rdg1 f5 22. hg6 hg6 23. b4 Qb4 24. Rg4 fg4 25. f5 Rc326. fg6 Rh3 27. Qb4 Rh1 28. Ka2 Kg7 29. e5 de5 30. Qb7Rhh8 31. Qe4 Kf6 32. Qg4 Reg8 33. b4 Rg6 34. Qf3 Kg735. Qe3 Re6 36. Qa7 Rd8 37. Qg1 Kf7 38. b5 Rdd6 39. c4 e440. c5 Rd2 41. Kb3 e3 42. Kc3 Rf2 43. c6 Rf5 44. Qb1 Kf645. Kd3 e2 46. c7 Rc5 47. b6 e1Q 48. Qe1 Re1 49. b7 Rc750. b8Q Rd7 51. Kc2 Re2 52. Kc3 Re3 53. Kc2 Rd6 54. Qh8Kg5 55. Qg8 Kf4 56. Qg2 Re5 57. Qh2 Kf5 58. Qh5 Ke659. Qg4 Rf5 60. Qe4 Re5 61. Qg4 Kd5 62. Qf3 Re4 63. Kd3Ke5 64. Kc3 Rdd4 65. Qh5 Kd6 66. Qg6 Kc7 67. Qg7 Rd668. Qh7 Re5 69. Qg7 Re3 70. Kc4 Re4 71. Kc3 Kd7 72. Qf7Re5 73. Kc4 Ra5 74. Kb4 Rdd5 75. Kc4 Rac5 76. Kb3 Re577. Qg6 Rf5 78. Qg7 Rce5 79. Kc4 Rg5 80. Qh7 Ref581. Kd4 Ra5 82. Ke3 Ra3 83. Kf4 Rga5 84. Qf7 Rc5 85. Ke4Rg5 86. Kf4 Rga5 87. Ke4 R5a4 88. Kd5 Ra5 89. Ke4 Rh390. Kf4 Kd6 91. Qg6 e6 92. Qe8 Ra4 93. Kg5 Rg3 94. Kh5Ra5 95. Kh4 Rga3 96. Qd8 Ke5 97. Qc7 Ke4 98. Qc4 Ke599. Qc7 Kf6 100. Qf4 Rf5 101. Qd4 Kg6 102. Qe4 Ra6103. Qc4 Rd6 104. Qc8 e5 105. Qg8 Kf6 106. Qf8 Ke6107. Qe8 Kd5 108. Qb5
n9531l

With today's endgame tablebases, an ending like this can be analyzed perfectly. The posted position is a draw. The position after move 48, when the material is reduced to seven men, is also a draw. In between moves 48 and 108, White never had a  chance for a winning move. Black had three chances to win following mistakes by White, and missed them all.

After White's 84.Qf7, Black could mate in 32 starting with 84...Rc3, but played 84...Rc5 and the position was again a draw.

After White's 87.Ke4, Black could mate in 33 starting with 87...Rh3, but played 87...R5a4+ and the position was again a draw.

On 89.Ke4 White returned to the same losing position, and this time Black played the winning Rh3. But then Black threw the win away with 90...Kd6. 90...Rc3 was the only winning move. That was the last chance for either side to win, before the game ended.

Dreaming may not be the best technique for solving an endgame, after all.