Puzzle algorithm change?

The current puzzly algorithm is really out of control, I think. Totally disaster. I hope they will fix it soon.

It's a multi part thing. There should be some communication around it but it's likely that and the other changes will happen closer in time to each other.

Even if the UI is going to be improved, there are real issues with these changes. I used to love puzzles and worked really hard for my rating which I felt was completely fair. Everyone had the same rating standards, so it really felt like a goal to achieve a higher rating.

Now, the rating is subject to whatever settings I chose. So what is the point of the rating now?

Even if the difficulty settings are fixed, If I have a 2200 rating with my settings set to extra hard and no hints and compare to someone else who got a 3200 rating by turning on hints and uses standard difficulty, how is that a fair comparison?

Further, if I solve extra hard puzzles now, I seem to get the same +5 as solving an easy puzzle. In the past, I'd see +10 +15, not any more.

Lastly, I used to see all of my puzzles solved, now I only see a shortened list. I liked being able to go back in time, pick a hard puzzle and try to solve it again to see if I improved. I can't do that anymore if I'm only seeing the first page of the puzzles.

I'm not understanding this change at all.

I still get quite a few over +5 , even on Hard difficulty

Regarding the puzzle archive, the website has always just had 25. I think old versions of the apps may have been different, but the apps haven't had UI changes vas part of the difficulty settings (though the settings impact app puzzle selection)

Yes, maybe you get some puzzles rated higher, but thats not for everyone the case. I mentionend that earlier, and you said, thats not a bug but part of the redesign.

Even with the same rating and setting, some people get lower and other higher rated puzzles. Again, this leads to the rating being not comparable anymore.

I only really used the premium membership for the puzzles - today I cancelled my subscription renewal after this recent change. I agree with the general sentiment here of the change eroding any sense of improvement through tracking the rating over time, or having friendly competition with friends and coworkers.

im really not sure what insane person thought this update would be a good idea

You should only lose points if it's wrong or you used a hint

I don't mean the coach hints, which I also disabled. Something like that has been a requested feature for a long time and likely useful for a large portion of members.

What I mean is the actual hint button, which counts as getting the puzzle wrong, same as if you actually chose the wrong move. Or at least I think it still works that way. I only use hints on purpose if I failed a few times

Same thing happened to me. I couldn't work it out (why I lost points, not the puzzle).

Thanks fellas, I was just getting more and more sceptic, bcs I couldn't pass 2k for a very long time despite grinding, then I suddenly made it and ezly progressed to 2.5k by now - and for each new rating achievement gained I got more and more sceptic about this.

I mean just check this curve. Lmao. Is there anyone that wouldn't get suspicious after this kind of improvement? I hope chess.com Support will reset my rating to idk 2k after they fixed this bug.

I think this is a bug... I've been spending 40 minutes on puzzles and when I solve it, I get +5. Sometimes (maybe 4-5 times now for the past 2 months) for a properly solved puzzle I get -20 or sth like that. Think it's a bug... very annoying one actually.

That change should be reverted. It makes no sense at all. Why would you not connect the rating to the difficulty?

I kept climbing, am at 3.2k meanwhile and the difficulty is slowly rising. If I'd had to guess, I'd say the Rating is basically halved in comparison to before. Like with 3.2k now it feels a bit like back then with 1.6k - so I think I'm almost back to my true rating. Will try to keep climbing until I hit a wall.

Here is an example of getting points subtracted after answering a puzzle correctly. I'm assuming it's because I answered in 35 seconds? I have no idea what caused my rating to decrease by -21 points, maybe the system thought I answered it wrong? (I didn't).
I wasn't playing speed puzzles, just normal puzzles. This kind of thing never happened to me before the recent updates.
There is a fundamental issue with the puzzle algorithm, I sincerely hope the old algorithm is restored and all of these settings are done away with. Really, the old system wasn't broken at all. It was challenging and fun. Now it feels just random. 
I guess I can feel good that I know I answered it correctly, but still...

Time to solve doesn't matter. Using a hint or reloading the page might cause that though.

The Difficulty setting was just something added but is only part of the overall changes to the system. There are back-end rating changes made as well and the UI is currently showing the old data (rating of puzzles for example). There is work being done to show the back-end ratings it UI and that should happen in the near future. My understanding is there will also be some type of communication around those changes when they happen.

I didn't use a hint or reload the page. The only thing different is by default all of these settings are turned on. Note the setting

Show chat hints
Get advice from Coach when you ask for a hint.
I absolutely did not ask for a hint. Is there a glitch with this setting then?