Who wins?

Sort:
Avatar of Crazychessplaya

In the position below, it is white's move. Which statement is correct?

A. White has a won game

B. Black wins no matter what white plays

C. It's a draw!

Avatar of RosarioVampire

A.

Avatar of Crazychessplaya

Care to elaborate?

Avatar of RosarioVampire

1.Qe8+ Kh7 2.Qe4+ Kg8 3.Kg6 (threatening Qd5+) Bf8 4.Qd5+ Kh8 5.Qf7 and black is powerless to stop mate.
1...Bf8 2.Qxf8+ Kh7 3.Qf7+ Kh8 4.Kg6, black is again helpless.

Avatar of Crazychessplaya

Correct, RosarioVampire!

Avatar of AlexSteer

A diagram I made form RosarioVampire's description.

Avatar of kunduk

A

Avatar of RosarioVampire

I never mentioned 4.Qe8 ~

Avatar of Crazychessplaya
tonydal wrote:

How about "D. Black is weird"?


 I'm saving these types of answers for the Endless Quiz in the Fun section...

Avatar of bastiaan

why not 5.Qf8#

Avatar of Skeptikill

very very good puzzle! i was veering towards draw as i missed Qe4+

Avatar of mwaltenburg
AlexSteer wrote:

A diagram I made form RosarioVampire's description.

 


This diagram would only lead to stalemate! No one would win!

Avatar of LordJones3rd

i think black could win.

Avatar of mwaltenburg

[COMMENT DELETED]

 

this comment was deleted because I was not online last night and this comment was not posted by me! I don't appreciate whoever hacked my account and posted this!

Avatar of GrantZierer

Well, white can't force mate without the queen getting captured so a1 or c1 would give a queen with no protection against it.

Avatar of JG27Pyth
A.
I think this basically covers the variations
Is this from Khelnitsky's (sp?) chess test, or chess tactics test... I like his format, with the A. wins. B.loses. C. draws answers... really makes you look at the position realistically instead of, "Oh White has a winning move I've got to find it"
Avatar of GrantZierer

By that postion c1 or a1 are great move. nice try but if you were trying to change my opinion about it you were wrong

Avatar of JG27Pyth

Maybe the variation given below changes your opinion Grantchamp?

Avatar of Eebster
grantchamp wrote:

By that postion c1 or a1 are great move. nice try but if you were trying to change my opinion about it you were wrong


JG27Pyth's diagram shows pretty clearly that white has forced mate. There are not "great moves" for black if he will be checkmated anyways.

Avatar of GrantZierer

i surrender