2. What's Godwin's Law supposed to be?
That someone will eventually be bound to mention Hitler. It's meaningless but it's meant as a put down.
The kid didn't even rise to the level of fking up with Goodwin's law because he was just repeating a random idea without any intent to suggest one thing or another.
The dissonance in here is... high.
No it's fine but considered reprehensible by the owners of online morality.