You need to do something different with banned posters on the forums.

Sort:
binomine

If a person is banned, all their forum posts, notes and chats are treated as they aren't there.

This is a problem for 3 reasons. 

1. Just because someone cheats, or is abusive, doesn't necessarily mean all their posts were worthless.  Even evil people can have valuable contributions, and throwing them out is throwing out the baby with the bathwater.   

2. It breaks the flow of the forum.  For example. if two people are chatting in notes, then one gets erased, it turns notes into gobbledygook. It is hard to build a community if your notes randomly become unreadable. 

3. If a banned person created a topic, then the first responder becomes the OP.  Often times, the first responder doesn't exactly WANT to be the OP.  Just this feature alone can lead to  some pretty trolly issues.  

pianomasterAA

True

30dayGRANDMASTERreturned

thanks for supporting me binominne

30dayGRANDMASTERreturned

🙂

IMKeto

"It is hard to build a community if your notes randomly become unreadable."

Have you seen the forums?  This isn't a community, it a village of idiots.

binomine
IMBacon wrote:

"It is hard to build a community if your notes randomly become unreadable."

Have you seen the forums?  This isn't a community, it a village of idiots.

The forums are a village of idiots, but usually notes are in clubs, and some clubs have a glimmer of hope. 

Itsameea

"Have you seen the forums?  This isn't a community, it a village of idiots."

Truer words have never been thus spoken before!!!!

Martin_Stahl
binomine wrote:

If a person is banned, all their forum posts, notes and chats are treated as they aren't there.

...

3. If a banned person created a topic, then the first responder becomes the OP.  Often times, the first responder doesn't exactly WANT to be the OP.  Just this feature alone can lead to  some pretty trolly issues.  

 

Banned members that create a post, have the whole post hidden. The only way that 3 happens if the OP deletes their initial post.

binomine
Martin_Stahl wrote:
binomine wrote:

If a person is banned, all their forum posts, notes and chats are treated as they aren't there.

...

3. If a banned person created a topic, then the first responder becomes the OP.  Often times, the first responder doesn't exactly WANT to be the OP.  Just this feature alone can lead to  some pretty trolly issues.  

 

Banned members that create a post, have the whole post hidden. The only way that 3 happens if the OP deletes their initial post.

Honestly, that seems even worse...

I can make any sort of troll-ish post, wait for the first reply, and then transfer ownership? That seems to be a terrible setup. 

Martin_Stahl
binomine wrote:

Honestly, that seems even worse...

I can make any sort of troll-ish post, wait for the first reply, and then transfer ownership? That seems to be a terrible setup. 

 

It didn't work like that in the past; not sure why it changed. That's why a lot of people quote the first post.

Bruvoskity

bump?

breezehappysquirrel

Like the “The forums are a village of idiots” 😆😭🤣

LordSupremeChess
#1 your #3 point has changed. Now the OP’s posts get entirely deleted.