Wang Yue & Grischuk share lead
Carlsen-Kamsky started with a theoretical discussion in a topical line of the Caro-Kann Defence. Carlsen's 19.g4 was a novelty, and a very interesting one. It allowed him to play in his usual style again: skilfully and energetically. Black wisely decided to return the pawn with 21?¢‚Ǩ¬¶Bf6! and after 23.Bb4 he has 23?¢‚Ǩ¬¶Re8 as an alternative, but Kamsky thought it to be too passive. According to the American GM, "White was pressing all the time but Black was solid enough to hold it." Don't miss the English version of Shipov's live analysis of this game, by the way.
White got a very nice position out of the opening in Grischuk-Adams. "10...e5 was clearly premature," Grischuk said, "because this 11.bxc5 bxc5 12.d4 is just very good for White. But then it was not so easy, because Black's pieces are always jumping; he's very active. OK, it's illusory activity, but it's also difficult to defend against illusory activity." Adams said he "probably mixed up two systems" in the opening and found 11.bxc5 bxc5 12.d4 very strong. "I thought my position would collapse soon but 19?¢‚Ǩ¬¶Ba4 was a good move." According to Grischuk, his king's bishop looked to be destined for the d5 square but having arrived there, there was nothing better than to exchange it, which led to an equal position. Sergey Shipov couldn't find a better way to play for White in this game: "For this we probably need somebody like Kramnik."An interesting ending was reached in Radjabov-Inarkiev, which started quite originally. "If I had seen these moves in an amateur game, I would have told them that they don't know opening principles," Sergey Shipov remarked. But a more profound analysis showed that the two GMs actually played quite reasonable and accurately. A sharp series of moves resulted in an extra pawn for Black, but White had good compensation. With Bf5 on move 29 or 30 he could have made life a bit more difficult for Black, according to Shipov.
In his own words, Wang Yue was "lucky to win this game" against Karjakin. And indeed, normally in the Ruy Lopez Berlin Wall a draw is both a likely result and the best Black can hope for. So what happened? After some fine defensive moves, Wang Yue had managed to equalize and then suddenly Karjakin lost his concentration and played a few dubious moves (25.Rd2?!, 28.Bb2?!), according to Sergey Shipov, and after the excellent reply 28?¢‚Ǩ¬¶Bg5! White faced some serious problems.Karjakin managed to keep things together but then made a big mistake in the rook ending. Instead of the automatic 36.Rxe6? it was necessary to activate the king with the move 36.Kf2! when 36...Ra3 37.Ke3! Rxb3+ 38.Ke4 Rc3 39.Rg6+! Kh5 40.Rxe6 Rxc4+ 41.Kf5 should be enough to draw.
In Cheparinov-Svidler, the last game that finished today, the Bulgarian went for the draw from move one, to get rid of that annoying zero in the standings, and he succeeded. At some point he even seemed close to a win. At the press conference Svidler compared the game to his encounter with Ivanchuk of last year and was of the opinion that "the simpler the position gets, the more attractive it starts to look for Black." In the ending Black was slightly better at some point but to Svidler's surprise, 30?¢‚Ǩ¬¶h5 seems to lead to equality only. "It looks ugly to take there, but Ivan's play in the game showed that it's probably the best move." After the Russian allowed 41.cxb5 cb5 42.Rc2 he suddenly had to go into defence move himself, but it wasn't too difficult to hold it.
Tomorrow is the first of two rest days; Sunday round 6 will be played.Links:
- Baku 2008 website
- Games in PGN