1 game between 2 amateurs hardly "proves" anything.
Hmm, it would prove something.
Nope, nothing.
What really is there to prove anyway? Ok so some people like to play crap and win with it, that's practical chess, and it can work a lot at amateur levels. I'd encourage them to play it, just gives me the upper hand early on. If I lose, I lose, but it's always nice to start with the advantage. Why do some people care so much about what openings other people play? It's not murder to play crap guys.
But yeah I don't know what draws people to like playing it with black, because really, it seems like you're defending your king for dear life the whole game, hoping your opponent screws up a couple tactics and that somehow you end up attacking. I think white would have most of the fun, as black's position is so fragile. Maybe it's the satisfaction of beating people who may think it's a forced loss? I have a more mature relationship with the game, so I don't get much joy out of that and don't take too hard losing to an inferior opening, as it's merely inferior after all and chess is no simple game!
1 game between 2 amateurs hardly "proves" anything.
Actually, what all this proves is that the urge to be Tarzan can be found everywhere.
I pity whoever gets to play the part of Jane