Forums

I Don't See the Point of the Touch-Move Rule

Sort:
TheGrobe

At this point, all threads are redundant.  I haven't seen an original thought in here in years.

Prayerman46

What annoys me is a player who moves his piece to a chosen square and keeps his finger on it as he surveys the board. Then he moves the piece back to it's original square if he changes his mind. Evidently the move is not completed until the piece is released. 

TheGrobe

It is not, however once he picks it up at least he's obligated to move that peice somewhere.

mrhjornevik
Prayerman46 wrote:

What annoys me is a player who moves his piece to a chosen square and keeps his finger on it as he surveys the board. Then he moves the piece back to it's original square if he changes his mind. Evidently the move is not completed until the piece is released. 

my brother does this. I let him get away with it more often than not, I also let him take back moves if he scream "no" quick enough :) Once he start beating me I might change, but for now it works ok 

MonsterRespawn
Prayerman46 wrote:

What annoys me is a player who moves his piece to a chosen square and keeps his finger on it as he surveys the board. Then he moves the piece back to it's original square if he changes his mind. Evidently the move is not completed until the piece is released. 

They should make another rule which would forbid you from taking your move back when you intentionally land your piece on a square, regardless of letting it go or not.

TheGrobe

Why stop there.  There should be a think move rule.  The first move you envision is the one you're you're obligated to make.

TheRealPhoenix
tubebender wrote:

WILL EVERYBODY PLEASE READ THE OFFICIAL RULES OF CHESS. iT`S NOT JUST FOR TOURNAMENT PLAYERS ONLY.

+1

December_TwentyNine
TheGrobe wrote:

Why stop there.  There should be a think move rule.  The first move you envision is the one you're you're obligated to make.

I love it. Ok. So imagine you're in some tournament. You're thinking about 3. Qxf7+. But then you realize that the Queen sacrifice that early in the game won't accomplish much for you. So instead, you develop a Knight.

Your opponent, who is FURIOUS, calls the arbitrator over and informs him that you were THINKING about a Queen sacrifice but instead played another move and DEMANDS you take your last move back.

Upon seeing the blank look on the arbitrator's face, I would more than likely LOL.

Here_Is_Plenty
TheGrobe wrote:

At this point, all threads are redundant.  I haven't seen an original thought in here in years.

Heartbreaker.

mrhjornevik
tubebender wrote:

WILL EVERYBODY PLEASE READ THE OFFICIAL RULES OF CHESS. iT`S NOT JUST FOR TOURNAMENT PLAYERS ONLY.

Why dont you read the title again? That way you can see that the the title is "I dont see the point of the touch move rule", not "there is no point tuch rule". 

I dont see the point of male nipples, that dont mean I dont think they excist. 

I could go on for some time, but hopfully you get the point :)

December_TwentyNine
tubebender wrote:

WILL EVERYBODY PLEASE READ THE OFFICIAL RULES OF CHESS. iT`S NOT JUST FOR TOURNAMENT PLAYERS ONLY.

Yes that may be but you are forgetting one minor detail.

 

In Soviet Russia, official rules of chess read YOU.

Here_Is_Plenty
mrhjornevik wrote:
tubebender wrote:

WILL EVERYBODY PLEASE READ THE OFFICIAL RULES OF CHESS. iT`S NOT JUST FOR TOURNAMENT PLAYERS ONLY.

Why dont you read the title again? That way you can see that the the title is "I dont see the point of the touch move rule", not "there is no point tuch rule". 

I dont see the point of male nipples, that dont mean I dont think they excist. 

I could go on for some time, but hopfully you get the point :)

Where else would you put the clamps?

Optimissed

<<Moving the rook first is also a complete move as soon as you remove your hand from the piece.>>

No it isn't, because you can't hop the rook over the king unless you castle, which you would do if you castle
. Therefore the rule to move the king first is illogical. 

Optimissed

It's a piece of silly pedantry that has no bearing on the game.

mrhjornevik
Optimissed wrote:

<<Moving the rook first is also a complete move as soon as you remove your hand from the piece.>>

No it isn't, because you can't hop the rook over the king unless you castle, which you would do if you castle
. Therefore the rule to move the king first is illogical. 

But If I castle on the queenside I wont need to pass the king

Here_Is_Plenty

Guys its not a rook move.  Castling is a king maneuver.  You cant move 2 pieces.  The rook is just dragged over by the board state, same as a piece dying is removed.

aman_makhija
aww-rats wrote:

If no touch move rule, you would distract your opponent easily. Say you pick up your Bishop, then notice your opponent will win elsewhere on the board. So, you let go of the bishop, and grab the Knight he is threatening, then see moving it loses too. You keep at this until you find the piece you can safely move. You have just succeeded in annoying your opponent and have broken his concentration. Therein lies the key. This is why tournament halls are silent. The touch move rule is just one of many rules meant to allow full concentration during a game.

So? Both sides have this disadvantage.

MuhammadAreez10
mrhjornevik wrote:
Optimissed wrote:

<<Moving the rook first is also a complete move as soon as you remove your hand from the piece.>>

No it isn't, because you can't hop the rook over the king unless you castle, which you would do if you castle
. Therefore the rule to move the king first is illogical. 

But If I castle on the queenside I wont need to pass the king

 

That's an illegal position. How did the queen and the bishop got there with no pawns moved?

Irontiger
TheGrobe wrote:

Why stop there.  There should be a think move rule.  The first move you envision is the one you're you're obligated to make.

Isn't that called "bullet chess"?

PS: the typonazi club informs you that underlining is not an acceptable form of emphasis in typed writing when bold or italics are possible.

mrhjornevik
[COMMENT DELETED]